Lost my plane!
#1
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 163
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: ModjadjiskloofLimpopo, SOUTH AFRICA
Bad day at the field.
Well, it started off well enough. I just finished putting together my brand new avistar with its brand new OS .46 ax engine and decided to maiden it today.
It flew great, much better than the flat bottomed trainer I am used to. In no time at all I was putting her through the basic moves, rolling, looping and then practicing touch and goes. It was a fantastic aircraft.
Then, all of a sudden, during level flight, she pointed her nose straight down, lost all radio control and disappeared into an area of woods. 3 hours of searching until the sun went down and no luck. It is raining and my plane is gone.
This has happened to me before, causing the destruction of my previous aircraft, and I thought it was because I had neglected to fully charge the receiver battery. This time I took no chances and charged the battery for 16 hours.
Other pilots were at the field and none of them noted any interference and none of them were close to my frequency. I can only conclude that my battery pack is faulty, losing its charge and causing servo lock.
This hurts. A lot.
It's not only the financial loss but going from the elation of flying something very well to utter despair.
Well, time to regroup and start again.
Ray
Well, it started off well enough. I just finished putting together my brand new avistar with its brand new OS .46 ax engine and decided to maiden it today.
It flew great, much better than the flat bottomed trainer I am used to. In no time at all I was putting her through the basic moves, rolling, looping and then practicing touch and goes. It was a fantastic aircraft.
Then, all of a sudden, during level flight, she pointed her nose straight down, lost all radio control and disappeared into an area of woods. 3 hours of searching until the sun went down and no luck. It is raining and my plane is gone.
This has happened to me before, causing the destruction of my previous aircraft, and I thought it was because I had neglected to fully charge the receiver battery. This time I took no chances and charged the battery for 16 hours.
Other pilots were at the field and none of them noted any interference and none of them were close to my frequency. I can only conclude that my battery pack is faulty, losing its charge and causing servo lock.
This hurts. A lot.
It's not only the financial loss but going from the elation of flying something very well to utter despair.
Well, time to regroup and start again.
Ray
#2
Very sorry to hear that. What kind of battery was it? Was it the standard Futaba flight pack? It's hard to believe it would go that bad that quickly, but I am no expert.
#3
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 1,159
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Woodville, WI
Really sorry to hear that...
It's one thing to have a plane crash beyond repair, at least you can salvage pieces.
It's totally another to have the plane... disappear.
Look again, remember to keep looking up, and always remember, a plane almost ALWAYS is further away than you think it is...
Hopefully you'll find it, and hopefully it won't be a total loss... If nothing else.. It'd be nice to have the outside chance of finding the cause of the problem...
It's one thing to have a plane crash beyond repair, at least you can salvage pieces.
It's totally another to have the plane... disappear.
Look again, remember to keep looking up, and always remember, a plane almost ALWAYS is further away than you think it is...
Hopefully you'll find it, and hopefully it won't be a total loss... If nothing else.. It'd be nice to have the outside chance of finding the cause of the problem...
#4
Do you have the capability to test your battery under a current load? Also I have seen where a loose connection in the on/off switch can have the same result. It will be acting just fine and from the vibration of operation the connection is lost and the plane stops responding. Other possibilities include problems inside your receiver or transmitter. My point is once a problem is identified check everything that you are qualified to check thouroughly and have a qualified person check everything else.
#5
Senior Member
Also check the switch and ALL connectors.
Sorry for the loss. When looking, look for flashes of color or pieces of wood. You will probably not see the whole plane until you're right on it. Keep looking up, too. It might not have come all the way down.
Dr.1
Sorry for the loss. When looking, look for flashes of color or pieces of wood. You will probably not see the whole plane until you're right on it. Keep looking up, too. It might not have come all the way down.
Dr.1
#7
Senior Member
Don't give up on finding it. I lost one in a deep, heavly overgrown creek bed and gave up after a couple weeks looking. There is a power line running parallel to the creek and I saw the power company out looking at lines. I went down and ask them to take a look for me, which they did. No luck so at that point, I gave up all hope. Some three months later, an Ex member of the club was at the field and the subject of my plane came up. He boldly said "I'll find it". and damn if he didn't the next day. The wing and landing gear were lost, but I got the engine batteries, receiver ane three of the five servos digital servos. I pulled the engine apart and cleaned it and it ran just fine. I charged the battery and it was fine. The receiver was sent in to Futaba for a check out and they replaced a second party crystal that I hand in it. The servos were fine. It laid out there through the rainy season, but the fuselage was like a tent over the stuff and everything that was found was OK.
Go back to the field and replay where it went down. Guessing the distance is a problem, but you may have a line to search, or at least a fan. Don't forget to look up also. Mine made it to the ground, but shead the wings, landing gear, and tail fins on the way through the canopy of the trees. Good luck.
Don
Go back to the field and replay where it went down. Guessing the distance is a problem, but you may have a line to search, or at least a fan. Don't forget to look up also. Mine made it to the ground, but shead the wings, landing gear, and tail fins on the way through the canopy of the trees. Good luck.
Don
#8
Senior Member
Stand exactly where you were when the crash happened. Sight the spot you last saw it. Use a compass to follow the straight line and you're bound to find it.
Dr.1
Dr.1
#9
Member
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 42
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Repentigny,
QC, CANADA
I almost one of my plane. I charche the battery for the night, and the next day iwent to flight.
I dint check the battery before flyinf. I took the plane in the air. the first turn the plane turn and then when up at the same time. I tought that my finger that make up. Second turn and the same thing happend, i landded .
check the receiver batteries and the voltage show 4.3v. i check the plane on ground and the plane responded errectic. So i quit flying and bought a new batteri pack.
I dint check the battery before flyinf. I took the plane in the air. the first turn the plane turn and then when up at the same time. I tought that my finger that make up. Second turn and the same thing happend, i landded .
check the receiver batteries and the voltage show 4.3v. i check the plane on ground and the plane responded errectic. So i quit flying and bought a new batteri pack.
#11
I have a voltwatch in all of my planes, but i also check with a volmeter every couple flights, all i really have the voltwatch for is to make sure i didn't leave the battery on. But as of determining that last flight i use the esv.
Austin
Austin
#12
What radio were you using, we have had a couple guys that lost planes using the 6ex. Futaba finally sent replacements for the tx"s. There was some type of glitch in them. I heard they stopped prod. on that model.
#13
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 163
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: ModjadjiskloofLimpopo, SOUTH AFRICA
Thanks for the replies and the advice.
I am going back to the field this morning to try to find it again, I really don't want to lose that engine.
The radio is a 6 channel JR and the receiver and battery are standard JR equipment.
I was flew about 4 10 minute flights before she went down.
I guess I have just learned the hard way that a volt meter is not an optional extra on the runway.
I am going back to the field this morning to try to find it again, I really don't want to lose that engine.
The radio is a 6 channel JR and the receiver and battery are standard JR equipment.
I was flew about 4 10 minute flights before she went down.
I guess I have just learned the hard way that a volt meter is not an optional extra on the runway.
#14
ORIGINAL: TZflyer
Thanks for the replies and the advice.
I am going back to the field this morning to try to find it again, I really don't want to lose that engine.
The radio is a 6 channel JR and the receiver and battery are standard JR equipment.
I was flew about 4 10 minute flights before she went down.
I guess I have just learned the hard way that a volt meter is not an optional extra on the runway.
Thanks for the replies and the advice.
I am going back to the field this morning to try to find it again, I really don't want to lose that engine.
The radio is a 6 channel JR and the receiver and battery are standard JR equipment.
I was flew about 4 10 minute flights before she went down.
I guess I have just learned the hard way that a volt meter is not an optional extra on the runway.
#16
Senior Member
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 2,613
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: no city,
AL
ORIGINAL: Dr1Driver
Stand exactly where you were when the crash happened. Sight the spot you last saw it. Use a compass to follow the straight line and you're bound to find it.
Dr.1
Stand exactly where you were when the crash happened. Sight the spot you last saw it. Use a compass to follow the straight line and you're bound to find it.
Dr.1
jess
#17
Senior Member
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 594
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: gilmer/nacogdoches,
TX
get a compass for sure! does our post time go off of the op's time zone? it is already 11/29 for TZflyer huh? thats cool, he is going to look for his plane and i just put my plane up for the evening a few hours ago!!
#18

Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 813
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Dickinson,
ND
ORIGINAL: Dr1Driver
Stand exactly where you were when the crash happened. Sight the spot you last saw it. Use a compass to follow the straight line and you're bound to find it.
Dr.1
Stand exactly where you were when the crash happened. Sight the spot you last saw it. Use a compass to follow the straight line and you're bound to find it.
Dr.1
Oh by the way make sure you check ARTF or RTF planes when you get them. When I got that Mustang the reciever switch was left on from factory and the battery was bad, that isn't what caused this crash, oops over aggresive flying and two stalls caused that one. I had to learn the hard way about that battery, I put that in my Nexstar and it was fine for about 5 mins or so the I lost elevator Aileron and throttle were ok for about another min but I wasn't set up for my landing yet I was close but not close enough. Well that time I got it on the ground with a broken prop and a bent front landing gear. So yes a good battery checker is a must, I said I had to learn the hard way but I'm not stupid.
Here is a good battery checker that will check under load and discharge batterys.
http://www3.towerhobbies.com/cgi-bin...&I=LXEYM6&P=ML
#19

I think I paid less than $20 for the Hobico ESV I bought a week or two ago at my LHS. Fortunately I had my old batteries tested before catastrophe by my instructor, but his catching what my $300+ Digital multimeter didn't have convinced me to buy the thing, (Actually the model multi meter I have was far more expensive new, but its about 15 years old so is prolly more like $100 or less now.[&:].) Course the test leads were another $10, but so what $25 or so for piece of mind and knowing that if you use the tools you have you are far less likely to lose a bird over batteries.
#20
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 163
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: ModjadjiskloofLimpopo, SOUTH AFRICA
Found my plane this morning!
An hours searching yielded results, found her hanging in a tree.
I took your advice and followed a straight line from where I was standing and the crash site was just quite a bit further away than I initially thought.
The damage isn't too severe, wing is dented and my tail came off but should be fixed and up in the air again next week.
Engine and radio gear is completely undamaged.
The servos were still moving this morning, so much much for my dead battery theory. I must be picking up some kind of interference.
This has caused two major crashes for me and I wont allow for a third, I am looking to buy a 2.4 ghz system. Have any of you had experience with this type of radio (its a spektrum)? Is it worth changing from my "conventional" radio?
Thanks for the help.
Ray
An hours searching yielded results, found her hanging in a tree.
I took your advice and followed a straight line from where I was standing and the crash site was just quite a bit further away than I initially thought.
The damage isn't too severe, wing is dented and my tail came off but should be fixed and up in the air again next week.
Engine and radio gear is completely undamaged.
The servos were still moving this morning, so much much for my dead battery theory. I must be picking up some kind of interference.
This has caused two major crashes for me and I wont allow for a third, I am looking to buy a 2.4 ghz system. Have any of you had experience with this type of radio (its a spektrum)? Is it worth changing from my "conventional" radio?
Thanks for the help.
Ray
#22
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 163
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: ModjadjiskloofLimpopo, SOUTH AFRICA
Thanks Jester,
I will definitely give it a full charge before getting up again.
I plugged all my servos in, and the battery still turns them in spite of being on all night. Guess it isn't the battery after all.
I spoke to someone who repairs JR radios and he thinks I may have damaged a filter in the rx in a previous crash and this might be causing the intermittent failures. I am going to buy a new rx today and see if that fixes my problem.
I will definitely give it a full charge before getting up again.
I plugged all my servos in, and the battery still turns them in spite of being on all night. Guess it isn't the battery after all.
I spoke to someone who repairs JR radios and he thinks I may have damaged a filter in the rx in a previous crash and this might be causing the intermittent failures. I am going to buy a new rx today and see if that fixes my problem.
#24
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2007
Posts: 341
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: San Francisco Bay Area,
CA
Ray, you have my best wishes with you, what a great story of loss and triumph. I think 2.4ghz is a great recommendation ... the cost is minimal compared to your heartache and potential financial losses.
- K
- K
#25

My Feedback: (12)
ORIGINAL: TZflyer
Thanks Jester,
I will definitely give it a full charge before getting up again.
I plugged all my servos in, and the battery still turns them in spite of being on all night. Guess it isn't the battery after all.
I spoke to someone who repairs JR radios and he thinks I may have damaged a filter in the rx in a previous crash and this might be causing the intermittent failures. I am going to buy a new rx today and see if that fixes my problem.
Thanks Jester,
I will definitely give it a full charge before getting up again.
I plugged all my servos in, and the battery still turns them in spite of being on all night. Guess it isn't the battery after all.
I spoke to someone who repairs JR radios and he thinks I may have damaged a filter in the rx in a previous crash and this might be causing the intermittent failures. I am going to buy a new rx today and see if that fixes my problem.


