Spoilers????
#2

My Feedback: (2)
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 513
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Castries, SAINT LUCIA
Hm this is only a guess.
If you had individual control of the spoilers on each wing and moved them differently (eg. one at a time or with different amounts of deflection)
they could I think in theory act somewhat like ailerons but if they both are actuated by the same amount simultaneously then they would likely do two things
1) slow the plane down
2) possibly cause a bit of a drop in altitude
where as flaps can act to slow a plane down and help with lift
If you had individual control of the spoilers on each wing and moved them differently (eg. one at a time or with different amounts of deflection)
they could I think in theory act somewhat like ailerons but if they both are actuated by the same amount simultaneously then they would likely do two things
1) slow the plane down
2) possibly cause a bit of a drop in altitude
where as flaps can act to slow a plane down and help with lift
#3
Yes. You can use spoilers to roll a plane if you lift only the side you wish to bank towards. I believe that is how the B-2 bomber does it. They function as spoilerons if triggered independantly (and proportionally vs. up or not) and can be thought of as 100% aileron differential. Note that you'll also be setting up some odd lift & drag differences in the wings and you'll probably need to compensate with rudder. I wouldn't be surprised some models (with non-dihedral symmetrical wings) might get some adverse yaw and dutch roll on you.
I have several models set to raise the ailerons on a slider switch to act as spoilers. It kills lift and allows the model to settle at a steeper angle. In this case they function both as ailerons and spoilers.
Flaperons are just the opposite - the ailerons can be mixed to drop together.
I have several models set to raise the ailerons on a slider switch to act as spoilers. It kills lift and allows the model to settle at a steeper angle. In this case they function both as ailerons and spoilers.
Flaperons are just the opposite - the ailerons can be mixed to drop together.
#4

My Feedback: (1)
ORIGINAL: shd3920
Do spoilers (such as on sailplanes) work the same as ailerons or flaps?
Do spoilers (such as on sailplanes) work the same as ailerons or flaps?
Spoilers Used on full scale sailplanes are not normally at all like what most modelers call flaperons.
Mid chord spoilers do not impart much pitching moment like trailing edge surfaces that reflex up.
What that means is mid chord spoilers cause virtually no tendency to dive or climb on deployment. The airplane will remain in the same attitude but just lose altitude at great rate. Trailing edge surfaces when used as spoilers will demonstrate pitch changes and the need to retrim.
Here is my original Quad Kaydet (it was lost on flight 29 to a midair) and you can see mid chord spoilers that I built into the airplane just for kicks. The results were rather dramatic, when deployed from level flight power at cruse the airplane would remain in the same but be falling flat at a very alarming rate and when retracted would instantly be right back at cruse with not pitch change instantly. There was no real purpose to then and it was just for fun, shock and awe. I did not set them up to function differentially as the airplane roll control was/is excellent. QK #2 was soon flying but I did not bother with the spoilers.
If one build mid chord spoilers they should always be inboard of the ailerons. The last thing one would want is to disturb the airflow over the ailerons on deployment.
John
#5

My Feedback: (-1)
I do have spoilerons set up in one of my Extras, just for fun too. Sometimes I will be too high for a landing and hit a switch and the plane will start to drop instantly!! At the same time I do have aileron control, kinda sorta. I just snap the switch back up and have full alieron control again and swoop in for a landing. It's fun but I can see a lot of surprised people running into trouble with them if you don't know what to expect. Same thing goes for flaperon. I have used them both on fun fly planes with good effect, the set up is not good for everyone though, sometimes it can cause a stall and bite you.
#6
Thread Starter

Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 1,610
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Pittsfield,
MA
OK, I don't like the idea of spoilers on my sailplane. How about ailerons? Is there any point in having ailerons on a sailplane? Can ailerons be built into a sailplane that does have them as an option?
#8
ORIGINAL: Allfat
Spoilers on sailplanes is actually a very good idea. If it is a hot day and you have a good sailplane, you might have trouble getting it down without spoilers.
Spoilers on sailplanes is actually a very good idea. If it is a hot day and you have a good sailplane, you might have trouble getting it down without spoilers.
Ailerons will work on some sail planes, not on others. If you're working with a polyhedral wing, ailerons aren't really necessary, just a good size rudder. If you have a wing with dihedral or a straight wing, then ailerons will be more effective. For thermal flying, unless you are going into competition (then you'll want a competition specific plane, but that's a topic for another day), a rudder/elevator/spoiler sailplane is going to be as effective anything else.
I've always flown my sailplanes 2 or 3 channel, 2-meter and standard class, preferably 3-channel.
Hogflyer
#9
Thread Starter

Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 1,610
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Pittsfield,
MA
So elevator, rudder, spoilers?
How do the spoilers work? One separate gimble stick (is that what they are called on the TX?) for each spoiler with 2 separate servos? Or one servo and one gimble stick operating the two spoilers like flaps?
How do the spoilers work? One separate gimble stick (is that what they are called on the TX?) for each spoiler with 2 separate servos? Or one servo and one gimble stick operating the two spoilers like flaps?
#10

ORIGINAL: shd3920
OK, I don't like the idea of spoilers on my sailplane. How about ailerons?Ailerons are nice.
Is there any point in having ailerons on a sailplane? Yes, but not mandatory depending on many things.
Can ailerons be built into a sailplane that does have them as an option?If this question is worded properly the answer is obviously YES.
OK, I don't like the idea of spoilers on my sailplane. How about ailerons?Ailerons are nice.
Is there any point in having ailerons on a sailplane? Yes, but not mandatory depending on many things.
Can ailerons be built into a sailplane that does have them as an option?If this question is worded properly the answer is obviously YES.
#11

ORIGINAL: shd3920
So elevator, rudder, spoilers?
How do the spoilers work? One separate gimble stick (is that what they are called on the TX?) for each spoiler with 2 separate servos? Or one servo and one gimble stick operating the two spoilers like flaps?
So elevator, rudder, spoilers?
How do the spoilers work? One separate gimble stick (is that what they are called on the TX?) for each spoiler with 2 separate servos? Or one servo and one gimble stick operating the two spoilers like flaps?
#12

http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/forumid_231/tt.htm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spoiler_(aeronautics)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_brake_(aircraft)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MljPRTtJHhU&NR=1 F-15 video of airbrake deployment
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spoiler_(aeronautics)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_brake_(aircraft)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MljPRTtJHhU&NR=1 F-15 video of airbrake deployment
#13
ORIGINAL: shd3920
So elevator, rudder, spoilers?
How do the spoilers work? One separate gimble stick (is that what they are called on the TX?) for each spoiler with 2 separate servos? Or one servo and one gimble stick operating the two spoilers like flaps?
So elevator, rudder, spoilers?
How do the spoilers work? One separate gimble stick (is that what they are called on the TX?) for each spoiler with 2 separate servos? Or one servo and one gimble stick operating the two spoilers like flaps?
I prefer to hook my spoilers up directly on a single servo to both open and close - not rely on a rubberband to close them. A bit more complex with bellcranks, but I like to have positive control over them. Some spoilers, when the rubberband return gets weak, can lift up a bit on their own and possibly spoil some lift. With direct servo contol that will only happen with a servo failure.
I know some who use a toggle switch or rotary switch for their spoilers, but I find the throttle stick easier. I've seen some guys with 2-meter gliders use the Hitec Focus 3 radio - the gimbal for rudder/elevator and the slider switch on the back for spoilers.
Hogflyer
#14
Thread Starter

Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 1,610
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Pittsfield,
MA
Can the spoilers be set up with two servos as you would ailerons? Then have the linkages go straight to the spoiler like an aileron would? What kind of Y-harness would you use for the two-servo setup to have the servo go the same way, instead of opposite like ailerons.
Flaps can be setup with two servos so why couldnt spoilers be hooked up the same way as flaps?
Spoiler installation photos and graphics would be great.
Flaps can be setup with two servos so why couldnt spoilers be hooked up the same way as flaps?
Spoiler installation photos and graphics would be great.
#16
Thread Starter

Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 1,610
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Pittsfield,
MA
ORIGINAL: Allfat
You could just have a regular y harness, just point the servos the same way instead of opposite ways when you do ailerons.
You could just have a regular y harness, just point the servos the same way instead of opposite ways when you do ailerons.
#18
Thread Starter

Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 1,610
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Pittsfield,
MA
ORIGINAL: Allfat
I don't see why not. It would add a little weight, but it should function fine.
I don't see why not. It would add a little weight, but it should function fine.
That would barely add any weight.
#19
ORIGINAL: shd3920
OK, I don't like the idea of spoilers on my sailplane. How about ailerons? Is there any point in having ailerons on a sailplane?
Can ailerons be built into a sailplane that does have them as an option?
OK, I don't like the idea of spoilers on my sailplane. How about ailerons? Is there any point in having ailerons on a sailplane?
Can ailerons be built into a sailplane that does have them as an option?
You WANT ailerons for full control.



