Gas radial engines
#476
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Brisbane, Australia
Posts: 305
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Question - I'm using the tuning method shared by Hector & Blair and my temps are fairly close to balanced, although my max temp are lower than experienced by others. My question is - when I throttle down from 75 - 100%, it takes 15 - 20 seconds before the idle settles at 1700-1800 RPM. Sometimes after finding idle, the RPM climbs up 400 RPM or so, before finally settling at 1700-1800.
Am I still a bit rich or is this normal?
Cheers
Am I still a bit rich or is this normal?
Cheers
Your modified FG33R3 or another engine? I was under the impression your Ray English engine was getting plenty of use in your Cub.
My FG 33R3 used to take a minute to come down to a stable idle, in truth it isnt a problem for most people that fly on a grass field as it takes more than 400 rpm increase to overcome the friction from the grass.
Cheers Blair
#477
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Brisbane, Australia
Posts: 305
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If its a Saito gas radial Morgans Coolpower blue works as well as any an i believe you can get it in the States.
cheers Bk
#478
Question - I'm using the tuning method shared by Hector & Blair and my temps are fairly close to balanced, although my max temp are lower than experienced by others. My question is - when I throttle down from 75 - 100%, it takes 15 - 20 seconds before the idle settles at 1700-1800 RPM. Sometimes after finding idle, the RPM climbs up 400 RPM or so, before finally settling at 1700-1800.
Am I still a bit rich or is this normal?
Cheers
Am I still a bit rich or is this normal?
Cheers
How far out is your Low and High?
I found a happy medium @ 7 out (Low) and >5 out (High).
Last edited by hpergm; 02-27-2015 at 04:44 AM.
#479
Mike, no need to sweat over the oil - we use Castrol simply because it is what's available over here at a reasonable quality/price ratio. You can use any good quality synthetic as long as it is not Ester-based. Ester -based premium oils (like Motul 800 and BelRay H1R) are more for injected systems - when premixed, the ester is known to affect o-rings and seals over time (in tank, carb).
#480
My Feedback: (9)
Hi Mark, what engine are you talking about?
Your modified FG33R3 or another engine? I was under the impression your Ray English engine was getting plenty of use in your Cub.
My FG 33R3 used to take a minute to come down to a stable idle, in truth it isnt a problem for most people that fly on a grass field as it takes more than 400 rpm increase to overcome the friction from the grass.
Cheers Blair
Your modified FG33R3 or another engine? I was under the impression your Ray English engine was getting plenty of use in your Cub.
My FG 33R3 used to take a minute to come down to a stable idle, in truth it isnt a problem for most people that fly on a grass field as it takes more than 400 rpm increase to overcome the friction from the grass.
Cheers Blair
Mark - I think this is a sign of LEAN. RPM jumps up @ idle because you quickly choke air; if rich, the engine would bog down fast. When Lean, the temporary air choking actually improves the burn if the fuel inside is towards lean (less air and less fuel = more stoichiometric), thus giving you temporarily higher rpm. Makes sense?
How far out is your Low and High?
I found a happy medium @ 7 out (Low) and >5 out (High).
How far out is your Low and High?
I found a happy medium @ 7 out (Low) and >5 out (High).
I think I'm done tuning - time to start flying!
Cheers
#481
Bad day, two months waiting for spare gaskets from RCJapan for my FG60 R3 and today have reached but without the gaskets that I need for cylinders and camshaft... a set of washers instead...
#482
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Brisbane, Australia
Posts: 305
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A scalpel, scissors and a normal nail held in a pair of vice grips, heat that nail red hot with cheap gas torch and it will follow the inside case profiles easily.
We made a full set of gaskets in 35 minutes. Another option is permatex paint on form in place gasket. Works great on gas but not glow as its alcohol affected.
Hope this helps, BK
#483
Thanks Blair, I will try to make the gaskets for myself ...yellow commercial envelopes...? can you show it please?
I have already submitted a claim to RC Japan anyway...
I have already submitted a claim to RC Japan anyway...
Last edited by Alex70; 03-23-2015 at 10:43 PM.
#484
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Brisbane, Australia
Posts: 305
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
cheers BK
#486
Senior Member
Alex I guess they could be described as a C4 kraft envelope, any paper thicker than standard printing paper will do. Head down to a news agent or art supplies store and most of the coloured card sheets available are in various thicknesses, just take your gasket and match the thickness.
cheers BK
cheers BK
For the cylinders, you could just use a thin film of silicone. A thinner gasket on the cylinder bases will affect compression slightly but the difference would have to approach .5mm to make much difference. The glow engines don't use cylinder base gaskets.
#487
Dear Alex, this sucks - but is very strange. I actually recommended RCJ to you and had absolutely no problem... The cylinder Gaskets were IN the set.
#488
Hola, I received several weeks ago a mail from RCJ that inform me that the order is with delay because some ítems are out of stock... I prefer that they don´t send me anything, I believe also that the big ring gasket not belong to my engine, are different that your gasket in size... I sent it a claim to RJC yesterday.
#489
Hi hpergm, this is the answer from RCJ to my issue:
"Thank you for your mail. We are a bit confused. The part you received is the same as the part number on your order. Please specify the part number you have an issue with and the part you required."
Wich is is the part number of your gasket set for FG60 R3 engine?
Thanks and regards.
"Thank you for your mail. We are a bit confused. The part you received is the same as the part number on your order. Please specify the part number you have an issue with and the part you required."
Wich is is the part number of your gasket set for FG60 R3 engine?
Thanks and regards.
#490
Holla Alex. The full gasket set is No.32, with the cylinder gaskets being 32-8. But, there's a catch - here's my correspondence with RCJ:
"Dear Mrs. Hope,
I am looking for a spare gasket set for my FG-60 R3 - part number is 32. I am particularly interested in 32-8 which is the base cylinder gaskets (somehow the parts list under 32 does not include that under the "32" set."
"Dear Mr. Hector,"Thank you for your patience. I am not sure I understand your question exactly, but you can either order Part 32 or you can order 32-8.
"Which do you need? Both are available."
"Dear Mrs. Hope,
Thanks for your reply.
To clarify: I am just trying to confirm that sub-part 32-8 is included in the full 32 set... Why? As you see, in the parts list of the engine, part 32 comprises -1, -2, -3, -4, -5, and -6 but -8 is not mentioned. This may be a typo error.
I would thus like to order: a full 32 set plus 3 x 32-8 gaskets."
"Dear Mr. Hector,
Thank you for your mail. I understand your inquiry. Yes, 32-8 is included in the Engine Gasket Set. It should be the error it is not writing on the list.
We will be adding it to the website for you to complete the order through the shopping cart system.
Thank you for your patience."
"Dear Mrs. Hope,
I am looking for a spare gasket set for my FG-60 R3 - part number is 32. I am particularly interested in 32-8 which is the base cylinder gaskets (somehow the parts list under 32 does not include that under the "32" set."
"Dear Mr. Hector,"Thank you for your patience. I am not sure I understand your question exactly, but you can either order Part 32 or you can order 32-8.
"Which do you need? Both are available."
"Dear Mrs. Hope,
Thanks for your reply.
To clarify: I am just trying to confirm that sub-part 32-8 is included in the full 32 set... Why? As you see, in the parts list of the engine, part 32 comprises -1, -2, -3, -4, -5, and -6 but -8 is not mentioned. This may be a typo error.
I would thus like to order: a full 32 set plus 3 x 32-8 gaskets."
"Dear Mr. Hector,
Thank you for your mail. I understand your inquiry. Yes, 32-8 is included in the Engine Gasket Set. It should be the error it is not writing on the list.
We will be adding it to the website for you to complete the order through the shopping cart system.
Thank you for your patience."
#491
Hola Hector,
Now I am a bit confused, in RCJ web the item number for FG60 R3 gaskets set is SA-60R3-32, there is not any subparts list under this item, see the picture that RJC show in his web for this item, seem the same of your set gaskets, is not the same set that I received from RCJ.
Please, can you post a picture of your set bag showing the item number?
Saludos.
Now I am a bit confused, in RCJ web the item number for FG60 R3 gaskets set is SA-60R3-32, there is not any subparts list under this item, see the picture that RJC show in his web for this item, seem the same of your set gaskets, is not the same set that I received from RCJ.
Please, can you post a picture of your set bag showing the item number?
Saludos.
Last edited by Alex70; 03-23-2015 at 12:06 PM.
#492
Alex,
Our part number is the same.
My reference in the post above was always to the engine instructions (see attached). Therein, the gasket set (Part -32) is listed out to contain certain sub parts which you could also get separately; namely -1, -2, -3, -4, -5 and -6. It is clear that -8 is (strangely) not included in that set and you would need to order it separately. Now, RCJ inquired about this to Saito following my notice and apparently Saito sent them a couple of -32 sets for me with the -8 included. It seems that Saito did not correct their mistake in subsequent dispatches of the -32 set - they may need reminding of this ommission from RCJ once again...
Bottom line is you need to order the 32-8 separately or find a cylinder gasket from the 21cc gas single from a European store (this was reported to be identical).
Saludos.
Our part number is the same.
My reference in the post above was always to the engine instructions (see attached). Therein, the gasket set (Part -32) is listed out to contain certain sub parts which you could also get separately; namely -1, -2, -3, -4, -5 and -6. It is clear that -8 is (strangely) not included in that set and you would need to order it separately. Now, RCJ inquired about this to Saito following my notice and apparently Saito sent them a couple of -32 sets for me with the -8 included. It seems that Saito did not correct their mistake in subsequent dispatches of the -32 set - they may need reminding of this ommission from RCJ once again...
Bottom line is you need to order the 32-8 separately or find a cylinder gasket from the 21cc gas single from a European store (this was reported to be identical).
Saludos.
Last edited by hpergm; 03-23-2015 at 11:01 PM.
#493
Hi Hector, understood. I received a answer from RCJ this morning:
"Thank you for your confirmation of this information. Please give us 1-2 days to process your request and inform you the next steps."
Thanks and regards, Alex.
"Thank you for your confirmation of this information. Please give us 1-2 days to process your request and inform you the next steps."
Thanks and regards, Alex.
#494
My Feedback: (4)
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: new castle,
DE
Posts: 79
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
thanks for all the info on the castrol oil.i am just going to stick with Stihl HP Ultra Premium synthetic at 20/1.have used this oil in zenoahs at 50/1 and all run great.soon as my DA 50 is broken in,i'll switch to it too.
#495
Hi Hector, this mail from RCJ that I received today looks good.
"Saito will send the parts which are not included. We expect to have them next week. Do you have another order to place soon and we can ship together?"
"Saito will send the parts which are not included. We expect to have them next week. Do you have another order to place soon and we can ship together?"
Last edited by Alex70; 03-26-2015 at 10:40 PM.
#496
I flew my FG60 yesterday for the first time, it certainty has plenty of power and is very similar in performance to a DLE 55. I'm running 15:1 mix. High speed needle is out 1.25 turns and Low speed is out 6.75 turns but it was still a bit rich on the low end so I will adjust this in the next few flights. I'm using a 23x8 Bela prop and got 6,200rpm
I used plenty of baffling in the cowl and put louvered vents behind each of the cylinders just to make sure everything stays cool.
I used plenty of baffling in the cowl and put louvered vents behind each of the cylinders just to make sure everything stays cool.
#498
My Feedback: (5)
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: , MI
Posts: 23
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
hello Gents
I just got my 450 Saito back from Ray, a wonderful person to work with. The engine has been converted to gas by C&H and then Ray massaged the rest. The carb was changed to the new F 82 carb after the internals were modified.After about 2 hours on the test bench it is happily turning a 23/8 prop at around 7400 rpm. oil is 20 to 1.
Cheers Joe..PS. Ray just finished my Saito 170 radial also with ignition but glow.
I just got my 450 Saito back from Ray, a wonderful person to work with. The engine has been converted to gas by C&H and then Ray massaged the rest. The carb was changed to the new F 82 carb after the internals were modified.After about 2 hours on the test bench it is happily turning a 23/8 prop at around 7400 rpm. oil is 20 to 1.
Cheers Joe..PS. Ray just finished my Saito 170 radial also with ignition but glow.
#499
Hi all, on my Saito FG 60-R3 I have a Keleo ring and I have attached the pressure feed from the ring to the tank and runing a 15:1 mix petrol to oil mix. I have a question about this as when I tune the engine in the ground it's fine but in the air it seems to get richer and loose power, do you think the pressure feed is therefore adding too much fuel to the carb during flight? Has anyone eles uesed the pressure feed from the exhaust to the tank?
my mixture settings are.
Low open to 6.25 turns
High open 1.25 turns
Any advice on weather to use the pressure from the Keleo exhaust or not would be helpful.
my mixture settings are.
Low open to 6.25 turns
High open 1.25 turns
Any advice on weather to use the pressure from the Keleo exhaust or not would be helpful.
#500
John, would it be possible in your installation that airspeed creates too much suction/vacuum in the cowl (close baffle, many louvres)? Rich can also be a result of too less air - and it does not take much difference to spoil the mixture...
Is your carb trumpet passing through the firewall (i.e. sucking air through the fuz plenum)? If you have used longer stand-offs than those supplied by Saito, you may be suffering from an effect like this..
Is your carb trumpet passing through the firewall (i.e. sucking air through the fuz plenum)? If you have used longer stand-offs than those supplied by Saito, you may be suffering from an effect like this..
Last edited by hpergm; 04-15-2015 at 01:23 PM.