Not Your Common Interference Problem
#1
Thread Starter

Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 1,329
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Houston, TX
I have been frustrated by this problem for some time. When I have my Quadra 42 w/magneto ignition running the servos go wild. At any range when above half throttle. I have changed radio gear to no effect. I shielded the aileron servo leads and have noise traps in the y-harnesses. Other basics are taken care of: no metal pushrods running forward, ball link connector on the throttle, and good separation between the radio gear and engine. Metal-to-metal vibration gremlins checked. I replaced the spark-plug and mag coil w/spark lead in a failed effort to kill the problem.
Yesterday I tested the plane with a different engine (US41 w/CH ignition) and the problem was completely gone. So now I know it is something in the engine rather than a weakness in the radio system. It is also not likely to be vibration related as that has not significantly changed.
This Quadra has been very good and reliable until now. It does have about 200 total hours on it, but I don’t consider that so much. I have run it successfully with an old Futaba 7-GK AM system (now running FM-PPM). I have run it successfully with the throttle servo right behind the firewall (since moved about 14” back). No problems.
What could be the cause of my interference? The complete ignition system is new. The bulk of the other causes I can think of still remain with the aircraft and have been eliminated. What else could be going on in that engine that would light up my radio gear?
I am at a loss.
Bedford
Yesterday I tested the plane with a different engine (US41 w/CH ignition) and the problem was completely gone. So now I know it is something in the engine rather than a weakness in the radio system. It is also not likely to be vibration related as that has not significantly changed.
This Quadra has been very good and reliable until now. It does have about 200 total hours on it, but I don’t consider that so much. I have run it successfully with an old Futaba 7-GK AM system (now running FM-PPM). I have run it successfully with the throttle servo right behind the firewall (since moved about 14” back). No problems.
What could be the cause of my interference? The complete ignition system is new. The bulk of the other causes I can think of still remain with the aircraft and have been eliminated. What else could be going on in that engine that would light up my radio gear?
I am at a loss.
Bedford
#2

My Feedback: (5)
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 5,768
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: San Tan Valley,
AZ
Try wrapping the spark plug lead and the spark plug with aluminum foil. Ground the foil firmly to the engine at the spark plug. If that helps get a Bosch spark plug cover from C&H.
If you replaced the spark plug make sure the sales clerk didn't slip you a non resistor plug.
Take the C&H system off the US41 and try it on the Quadra. If it fixes the problem get rid of the mag
If you replaced the spark plug make sure the sales clerk didn't slip you a non resistor plug.
Take the C&H system off the US41 and try it on the Quadra. If it fixes the problem get rid of the mag
#3
Senior Member
My Feedback: (14)
"The complete ignition system is new"
---------------
Did the interference begin after the ignition system was replaced? Or was the replacement an effort to quell the preexisting problem?
Having 200 hours on an engine must make you proud. It would me. However, things do wear and get loose after a while - or could be what's causing the problem. Maybe it isn't. I'll bet you have gone over this engine with a fine tooth comb, but I wonder about such things as the choke plate, or even the carb shafts for the choke and the main throttle plate. Any looseness there? Yes, I'm really stretching, but there must be an answer.
How are the coil mount threads? Any sheet metal in that vicinity that could be vibrating?
Others have already pointed out the ignition ground and plug shielding. This would really make a great follow up thread, if you're in the mood. Good luck.
---------------
Did the interference begin after the ignition system was replaced? Or was the replacement an effort to quell the preexisting problem?
Having 200 hours on an engine must make you proud. It would me. However, things do wear and get loose after a while - or could be what's causing the problem. Maybe it isn't. I'll bet you have gone over this engine with a fine tooth comb, but I wonder about such things as the choke plate, or even the carb shafts for the choke and the main throttle plate. Any looseness there? Yes, I'm really stretching, but there must be an answer.
How are the coil mount threads? Any sheet metal in that vicinity that could be vibrating?
Others have already pointed out the ignition ground and plug shielding. This would really make a great follow up thread, if you're in the mood. Good luck.
#4

My Feedback: (14)
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 1,467
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Arlington,
TX
The following things apply more to older systems but could happen if there is a defect in a new component.
There are a couple of other things that can cause the magneto system to generate interference at the higher speeds.
One is the coil is starting to break down but has not fully failed.
The other is a failing plug wire or boot that breaks down when the cylinder pressure builds at higher speed causing the plug gap resistance to increase which in turn causes leakage thru the wire or boot insulation.
The coils can get noisey when the speed increases and the magneto shoots more voltage to them causing a partial breakdown of the coil insulation.
There are a couple of other things that can cause the magneto system to generate interference at the higher speeds.
One is the coil is starting to break down but has not fully failed.
The other is a failing plug wire or boot that breaks down when the cylinder pressure builds at higher speed causing the plug gap resistance to increase which in turn causes leakage thru the wire or boot insulation.
The coils can get noisey when the speed increases and the magneto shoots more voltage to them causing a partial breakdown of the coil insulation.
#6
Thread Starter

Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 1,329
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Houston, TX
The coil and plug were changed to address the problem. So it existed before the change. The plug is confirmed to be correct. I buy my plugs from CH or Bennett and they don't slip anybody the wrong product.
Pile-O-Wood, I have heard that too, but only with regard to helis. I have thought about this possibility, but in all the threads over the past years, I have not heard that suggestion for gassers. Anybody have confirmed experience with engine bearing noise causing the problem?
Thanks everyone for your input.
Bedford
Pile-O-Wood, I have heard that too, but only with regard to helis. I have thought about this possibility, but in all the threads over the past years, I have not heard that suggestion for gassers. Anybody have confirmed experience with engine bearing noise causing the problem?
Thanks everyone for your input.
Bedford
#7
Senior Member
Is the Quadra with the contact breaker ignition like the 34? Then clean up the contact points, and replace the condenser as well.
#9
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 107
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: lake charles,
LA
had a g26 do the same thing after i changed the pick up. the problem on that was the clearance between the flywheel & the pickup was to close.
#10
Thread Starter

Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 1,329
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Houston, TX
Haven't tried the aluminum foil, yet. Will get to it when possible.
For crashhappy: I set the coil gap per spec when I installed the new one. Thanks for the idea, but I don't think that's it.
Bedford
For crashhappy: I set the coil gap per spec when I installed the new one. Thanks for the idea, but I don't think that's it.
Bedford
#12
Thread Starter

Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 1,329
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Houston, TX
Thanks, Terry.
Can you descibe the complete installation using the Bosch rsistor cap on a magneto engine. I will get you you soon for a couple and some spark plugs.
Bedford
Can you descibe the complete installation using the Bosch rsistor cap on a magneto engine. I will get you you soon for a couple and some spark plugs.
Bedford



