BME Xtreme update
#77
Thread Starter
Banned
My Feedback: (1)
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 1,222
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: concord, NC
yeah, but what do you do when the engine is DESIGNED for a "quiet system", and makes 400-500 more rpm with a nice silent tuned system??
I really doubt you'd complain about the known power loss, would you?
I really doubt you'd complain about the known power loss, would you?
#78
This old geezer likes quiet engines -
When we were running pipe tests Tuesday - it was interesting to note that the setup which spun the biggest prop - the hardest - also had the best throttle response and-- was almost the quietest .
I do like small block Chevs that turn 8000 and Suzuki bikes that zing to wild revs - but noisy models just for noise sake - nope
When we were running pipe tests Tuesday - it was interesting to note that the setup which spun the biggest prop - the hardest - also had the best throttle response and-- was almost the quietest .
I do like small block Chevs that turn 8000 and Suzuki bikes that zing to wild revs - but noisy models just for noise sake - nope
#79
Believe me, I love loud high performance engines and supersonic props, but we are losing flying fields at an alarming rate. We must diligently pursue quiet set-ups if this hobby is to continue to grow and prosper.
#81
If the models were on the ground - the noise would not be an issue.
We share a big wetlands with a off road training course and one can hear the bikes and 4 wheelers- only occasionally
A 150 tho -on in cowl "mufflers"
and a 32x10 prop - puts out noise which can be heard for MILES!
This is not idle talk - The in air noise IS an issue.
We share a big wetlands with a off road training course and one can hear the bikes and 4 wheelers- only occasionally
A 150 tho -on in cowl "mufflers"
and a 32x10 prop - puts out noise which can be heard for MILES!
This is not idle talk - The in air noise IS an issue.
#82
Thread Starter
Banned
My Feedback: (1)
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 1,222
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: concord, NC
I once used an AM 33-11 two blade on my Twin Spark 3W150, with pefa Canisters, and JUST to convince the Executive council of my flying club that noise WAS in issue, I did a demonstration takeoff for them.
I started at the right end of the runway, and just nailed the throttle. the 42 lbs DR109 was off the ground in 10 feet, ripping the prop as it passed center runway at an altitude of 5 feet, then I went about a quarter mile and did a downwind turn, still maintaining about 10 feet of altitude and headed down the back straightaway of the pattern. The prop was SOO loud that everyone on the committee was yelling at me to shut her down. I brought the engine back to idle,coasted in and landed, and for the next minute you could hear the props scream echoing off all the treelines more than a mile away, and the one directly behind the runway. . over and over again.
I never used that prop again, and at the next club meeting we had a unanimous vote to follow the IMAC noise regulations being proposed at that time, and to prohibit intentional prop ripping. Our field has been, and will continue to be, very quiet since that time.
I started at the right end of the runway, and just nailed the throttle. the 42 lbs DR109 was off the ground in 10 feet, ripping the prop as it passed center runway at an altitude of 5 feet, then I went about a quarter mile and did a downwind turn, still maintaining about 10 feet of altitude and headed down the back straightaway of the pattern. The prop was SOO loud that everyone on the committee was yelling at me to shut her down. I brought the engine back to idle,coasted in and landed, and for the next minute you could hear the props scream echoing off all the treelines more than a mile away, and the one directly behind the runway. . over and over again.
I never used that prop again, and at the next club meeting we had a unanimous vote to follow the IMAC noise regulations being proposed at that time, and to prohibit intentional prop ripping. Our field has been, and will continue to be, very quiet since that time.
#83
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 3,262
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Hammond,
IN
Ah noise control. Reminds me of an idiot Chicago Alderman (Burton Nataros) who tried to pass an ordinance in the City Hall to ban motorcycles from his neighborhood after dark. He didn't like the sound of wailing open pipes. It didn't pass. There's already laws on the book that say your vehicle (any vehicle) has to have a working muffler.
#85
Thread Starter
Banned
My Feedback: (1)
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 1,222
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: concord, NC
That's okay. . only so much conjecturing you can do on the Xtreme until it gets here. . and after they start flying, there will be nothing but arguing. . .
#89
Senior Member
They are Tim D. you just dont know it yet. Our high altitude test guy is getting as much as 600 rpm more than one of your favorite brand X engines at his field on the same exact prop. Both running stock mufflers and the BME is two lbs lighter. I can tell by his voice on the phone that his grin is way bigger than your smiley face on your post.
Keith
Keith
#92
Senior Member
Mike,
All I can tell you is very soon. If you are not on our list it may take until October or later to fill an order. We have over 500 people on the list now. If you are interested we need to add you to the list ASAP. This engine is kicking some serious but.
Keith
All I can tell you is very soon. If you are not on our list it may take until October or later to fill an order. We have over 500 people on the list now. If you are interested we need to add you to the list ASAP. This engine is kicking some serious but.
Keith
#95
Senior Member
Diablo, I haven't tested the Menz 27x10 but a MCS 27x10 which is a heavier load is turning 6300-6400. The Mejzlik 28x10 is turning 6700 and a 26x10 menz is turning 7100. This is on stock mufflers and and a new non broken-in engine. This engine is designed for tuned exhaust with a exhaust port duration of 170 degrees.
Keith
Keith
#98
Senior Member
All we need from you to add you to the list is your phone number and your patience with us. We are behind schedule for these engines but they will be well worth the wait. We plane on selling the 55X for 579.00.
Keith
BME
Keith
BME




