Axe CP brushles upgrade trouble. Warning, kind of long
#1
Thread Starter

Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: , CA
So I'm pretty new to the new heli thing. Been into RC cars for as long as I remember.
I've got an Axe CP, never really learned how to fly it well, but being a mechanical engineer dealing with automation and high technology such as brushless servo motors, I just had to put a Hyperion P1919 M06 motor on it, put a 15tooth pinion on it. Worked OK for a few days, I also paired the motor with a 35A hyperion ESC. I love the adjustability. And just to let you know I did go overboard here, I've been fully expecting to upgrade to a Trex or similar, it is just way too windy for the Axe where i live.
So now the problem. After a few flights and crashes(have checked linkages and main shaft, everything is very smooth and straight there) and what not, I could not get the tail to hold at all. This was upgraded with a gy240, when I bought a 7ch futaba heli radio. (going to be getting into planes here as well) I set the radio curves very simply, measure my min and max pitch, followed some advice with the collective mixing, and everything worked out great.
Then I started frying direct drive tail motors trying to keep the machine from spinning. Figured I needed more tail power so I upgraded to a little terror of a hyperion 12mm motor direct driving the tail. Helped a bit but over heated and shut down.
Is there something obvious I'm missing here? Oh, forgot to mention that I'm running plastic trainer blades.
Please give my overly obsesive techno brain some advice.
Regards,
Steve
I've got an Axe CP, never really learned how to fly it well, but being a mechanical engineer dealing with automation and high technology such as brushless servo motors, I just had to put a Hyperion P1919 M06 motor on it, put a 15tooth pinion on it. Worked OK for a few days, I also paired the motor with a 35A hyperion ESC. I love the adjustability. And just to let you know I did go overboard here, I've been fully expecting to upgrade to a Trex or similar, it is just way too windy for the Axe where i live.
So now the problem. After a few flights and crashes(have checked linkages and main shaft, everything is very smooth and straight there) and what not, I could not get the tail to hold at all. This was upgraded with a gy240, when I bought a 7ch futaba heli radio. (going to be getting into planes here as well) I set the radio curves very simply, measure my min and max pitch, followed some advice with the collective mixing, and everything worked out great.
Then I started frying direct drive tail motors trying to keep the machine from spinning. Figured I needed more tail power so I upgraded to a little terror of a hyperion 12mm motor direct driving the tail. Helped a bit but over heated and shut down.
Is there something obvious I'm missing here? Oh, forgot to mention that I'm running plastic trainer blades.
Please give my overly obsesive techno brain some advice.
Regards,
Steve
#2
Junior Member
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 15
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: JUNEAU, AK
did you try adjusting the gain on the gy 240? there is also a switch on there to go from normal to rev try switching it to rev. you may have tried this already but you didn't say, anyways i had the same problems.
anderson
anderson
#3
Thread Starter

Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: , CA
Yes, I've adjusted the gain, and the switch is set correctly. I can make it spin like a top with the rudder, but only if main rotor isn't spining.
Maybe the training blades just are effecient enough, I'm not sure, I think that is the next thing I'll try.
Thanks for the suggestions.
Steve
Maybe the training blades just are effecient enough, I'm not sure, I think that is the next thing I'll try.
Thanks for the suggestions.
Steve
#4
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 865
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: baltic,
CT
I thinky your main motor is way to much for the tail motor to compensate for the torque put the brushed motor back on the main and you will be fine (im running the stock brushed main motor, and a brushless tail motor setup a 12-30-3850 sized motor and a 12A esc and a telebee HH gyro)
#5
Thread Starter

Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: , CA
Yeah, the main motor is wwaaaay to powerful for the machine. This should not matter when geared correctly though. I had a 15 tooth pinion on it, so I think the head speed was way to high.
I did actually make some headway though. I dropped the main motor pinion down to a 12 tooth and turned off the speed limiting for now.
Tail actually snaps back from 45 degrees if I put in too much throttle too fast. Only problem is the tail motor does get a little toasty.
So it is either heat sink the tail motor, or go back to the stock main motor. Brushed main motor is probably the best way to go, but damn I love all the adjustments on the Hyperion speed control.
I'm still thinking I'm going to put the brushed back on, until I can get my skills a lot better and actually be able to use the good hyperion gear.
Thanks for all your help! Even though my local HS sells choppers, they are not very knowlegable, so it is great to have this forum.
Steve
I did actually make some headway though. I dropped the main motor pinion down to a 12 tooth and turned off the speed limiting for now.
Tail actually snaps back from 45 degrees if I put in too much throttle too fast. Only problem is the tail motor does get a little toasty.
So it is either heat sink the tail motor, or go back to the stock main motor. Brushed main motor is probably the best way to go, but damn I love all the adjustments on the Hyperion speed control.
I'm still thinking I'm going to put the brushed back on, until I can get my skills a lot better and actually be able to use the good hyperion gear.
Thanks for all your help! Even though my local HS sells choppers, they are not very knowlegable, so it is great to have this forum.
Steve
#6
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 511
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Southwick, MA
Toss the electric tail motor and get yourself the Belt-Drive kit, or the new shaft-driven (torque-tube kit). There is NO comparision between the WEAK & WIMPY [:'(] (ETM), and a DRIVEN tail rotor with true positive & negitive pitch
!
Did the conversion over 2yrs ago on my AXE CP v1, and never looked at an Electric-tail again!
Also, your BL main motor is way more powerful than you really need, your headspeed must be somewhere around 2800 RPM's!
To figure out the headspeed in RPM's= (Motor Kv * Nominal battery voltage * 90% effiency * Motor Pinion tooth count)/Main gear count. EXAMPLE: 3700*11.1*.9*14/186= 2782 rpm's
Shadow
!Did the conversion over 2yrs ago on my AXE CP v1, and never looked at an Electric-tail again!
Also, your BL main motor is way more powerful than you really need, your headspeed must be somewhere around 2800 RPM's!
To figure out the headspeed in RPM's= (Motor Kv * Nominal battery voltage * 90% effiency * Motor Pinion tooth count)/Main gear count. EXAMPLE: 3700*11.1*.9*14/186= 2782 rpm's
Shadow
#8
Junior Member
Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Lake Hopatcong, NJ
ORIGINAL: Shadow99
Toss the electric tail motor and get yourself the Belt-Drive kit, or the new shaft-driven (torque-tube kit). There is NO comparision between the WEAK & WIMPY [:'(] (ETM), and a DRIVEN tail rotor with true positive & negitive pitch
!
Did the conversion over 2yrs ago on my AXE CP v1, and never looked at an Electric-tail again!
Also, your BL main motor is way more powerful than you really need, your headspeed must be somewhere around 2800 RPM's!
To figure out the headspeed in RPM's= (Motor Kv * Nominal battery voltage * 90% effiency * Motor Pinion tooth count)/Main gear count. EXAMPLE: 3700*11.1*.9*14/186= 2782 rpm's
Shadow
Toss the electric tail motor and get yourself the Belt-Drive kit, or the new shaft-driven (torque-tube kit). There is NO comparision between the WEAK & WIMPY [:'(] (ETM), and a DRIVEN tail rotor with true positive & negitive pitch
!Did the conversion over 2yrs ago on my AXE CP v1, and never looked at an Electric-tail again!
Also, your BL main motor is way more powerful than you really need, your headspeed must be somewhere around 2800 RPM's!
To figure out the headspeed in RPM's= (Motor Kv * Nominal battery voltage * 90% effiency * Motor Pinion tooth count)/Main gear count. EXAMPLE: 3700*11.1*.9*14/186= 2782 rpm's
Shadow
Can You tell me where You saw the new shaft driven(torque tube) kit for the axe cp?
#9
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 1,027
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Benton Harbor,
MI
You can try the heat sink on the Hyperion tail motor to keep it cool, but I would recommend a larger tail motor and even a larger tail blade. I'm running a 10 gram brushless outrunner and a GWS 4.5x 3 prop.



