rc vs. real
#2
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 1,415
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Town Creek,
AL
rdd : why do rc helis have stab paddles but real (people) helis dont?
RC's use little electric servomotors that can only provide so much force. It requires less force to twist the paddles AOA. So for cyclic movement, the swash movement changes the AOA of the paddles instead of the AOA of the main rotor blades. This articulation of the paddles cause the flybar to teeter thus changing the main rotor AOA. The long leverage of the flybar does all the grunt work for cyclic. If you tried to create an electric servo that can provide the necessary force, it would be the size of a 1/4 scale servo (or more) and would probably need a large battery to drive it. Due to weight and size constraints ... this simply wouldn't be practical. So manipulating the main rotors via the flybar to harness aerodynamic power/leverage is used instead.
Real helis have things that literally provide much more force ... a human connected to a 2 to 3 foot lever (cyclic stick). This "human servo" connected to an adequate lever can provide plenty of force to manage the full size helis swash. Even with that, some helicopter controls are hydraulic assisted.
Human power, leverage, and hydraulic assist provide enough force to easily control the swash thus negating the necessity for other cyclic devices (flybar).
Good Luck,
d.tipton
#5

My Feedback: (11)
That and the fact that real helicopters don't need the cyclic or collective range that we use. You wont see many full scale helicopters doing tic-tocs or stationary flips.
The flybar system also provides some gyroscopic stability for the rotor system which you can see in the old MASH Bell 47's, the Huey's and some others in the form of weights.
I found that flying around in a full scale helicopter, not doing anything remotely violent, you pretty much just had to think about which way to turn and the heli would start heading in that direction.
The flybar system also provides some gyroscopic stability for the rotor system which you can see in the old MASH Bell 47's, the Huey's and some others in the form of weights.
I found that flying around in a full scale helicopter, not doing anything remotely violent, you pretty much just had to think about which way to turn and the heli would start heading in that direction.



