Viability of sharing a turbine between 2 models..
#26
My Feedback: (54)
Not sure the reason for this, but I have run into the issue with both Jet Cat and now Evo. Not sure the reason for Kingtech, but have a feeling it is the same reason. One ECU will keep track of the total time of the turbine. When operating the same turbine off of two ECU's, the total time isn't the same between the ECU, thus showing a different Total Time. Bob W. blew me off on this, and now at EVO, we are looking into this issue. This is why.......IMHO.....as to why Kingtech would void the warranty, is because it isn't an accurate time of the engine. It is BS when any of the manufactures say Total Time is stored in the engine. Retire Jet Capt here, so very funny about keeping proper time of engines from my professional days.
Last edited by RCFlyerDan; 05-29-2014 at 05:55 AM.
#27
My Feedback: (2)
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: CORAL GABLES,
FL
Posts: 234
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Exactly what they said ref time on engine, very easy solution would be for the manufacturer to document the specific turbine with two ecu's and request for any service or warranty work that the customer must send both ecu's to verify total time.
J.C.
J.C.
#28
My Feedback: (54)
Issue also becomes with resale of the engine to others. A Jet owner, could actually buy another ECU for an engine that has 25+ true hours on the engine, then list it on RCU, or some other place and sell it with another ECU that says it only has 4 hours. IMHO.....all of the manufactures have this undisclosed issue.
#30
My Feedback: (11)
Real jet engines I worked on dont care about time. What they care about are "tacs", or the number of rotations the High Pressure Turbine makes. If you think about it, this makes more sense. 25 hours at idle is not the same as 25 hours at full throttle.
How do I know? Well I am not a real pilot, which is good because a real pilot doesnt know jack about jet engines. I was jet engine mechanic in the air force for 4 years. Damn good one too. Its the main reason I am into jets now.
I wish they would go to tacs because then I can "stretch" my turbine's use by keeping the tacs lower. I also think it would also be more reliable since if you couple it with time, it shows how the engine is being used. Low Time, high tacs = essyou35's viper jet.
How do I know? Well I am not a real pilot, which is good because a real pilot doesnt know jack about jet engines. I was jet engine mechanic in the air force for 4 years. Damn good one too. Its the main reason I am into jets now.
I wish they would go to tacs because then I can "stretch" my turbine's use by keeping the tacs lower. I also think it would also be more reliable since if you couple it with time, it shows how the engine is being used. Low Time, high tacs = essyou35's viper jet.
#31
My Feedback: (54)
How do I know? Well I am not a real pilot, which is good because a real pilot doesnt know jack about jet engines. I was jet engine mechanic in the air force for 4 years. Damn good one too. Its the main reason I am into jets now.
I wish they would go to tacs because then I can "stretch" my turbine's use by keeping the tacs lower. I also think it would also be more reliable since if you couple it with time, it shows how the engine is being used. Low Time, high tacs = essyou35's viper jet.
I wish they would go to tacs because then I can "stretch" my turbine's use by keeping the tacs lower. I also think it would also be more reliable since if you couple it with time, it shows how the engine is being used. Low Time, high tacs = essyou35's viper jet.
Last edited by RCFlyerDan; 05-29-2014 at 07:14 AM.
#32
My Feedback: (11)
Well the pilots I knew didnt. They were fighter pilots allegedly engaged in combat during the bosnian conflict. Maybe commercial pilots or rc pilots know alot more for some reason?
I had go start the jet so many times for them because they have bleed air switches wrong or couldnt get the APU to couple. Feel free call the air force and let them know they are doing it wrong.
I really dont care how our toy turbines keep track of anything, I just use this as a way to have a small connection to my service in the air force. It reminds me at one time I used to do something cool and there is basis in what I say about jet engines. But since flying RC jets I am learning everything I know is wrong...
I had go start the jet so many times for them because they have bleed air switches wrong or couldnt get the APU to couple. Feel free call the air force and let them know they are doing it wrong.
I really dont care how our toy turbines keep track of anything, I just use this as a way to have a small connection to my service in the air force. It reminds me at one time I used to do something cool and there is basis in what I say about jet engines. But since flying RC jets I am learning everything I know is wrong...
#33
My Feedback: (54)
Well the pilots I knew didnt. They were fighter pilots allegedly engaged in combat during the bosnian conflict. Maybe commercial pilots or rc pilots know alot more for some reason?
I had go start the jet so many times for them because they have bleed air switches wrong or couldnt get the APU to couple. Feel free call the air force and let them know they are doing it wrong.
I really dont care how our toy turbines keep track of anything, I just use this as a way to have a small connection to my service in the air force. It reminds me at one time I used to do something cool and there is basis in what I say about jet engines. But since flying RC jets I am learning everything I know is wrong...
I had go start the jet so many times for them because they have bleed air switches wrong or couldnt get the APU to couple. Feel free call the air force and let them know they are doing it wrong.
I really dont care how our toy turbines keep track of anything, I just use this as a way to have a small connection to my service in the air force. It reminds me at one time I used to do something cool and there is basis in what I say about jet engines. But since flying RC jets I am learning everything I know is wrong...
#35
My Feedback: (4)
But you are right too, there are things that can get you in trouble too, for example, if your max RPM's are different between models (to adapt thrust to size) you have to make sure you have the right setting (ask my dad about taking off an F100 on grass, with a titan at 112K RPM... and of course, somehow it was my fault haha).
I guess it all depends on how many jets you have too. If you have 2 jets, then ok, have two turbines. they will get excercised and the cost is manageable. Go up to 4 or 5 jets, then it stop making sense to equip each and all of them (at least for me)
#36
Using one turbine between two (or more) a/c seems like a lot of work to do, but would ultimately depend on type of a/c involved. Turbines mounted on the outside of an a/c would be pretty simple I'd think compared to turbines "buried" deep inside of a fuse type of a/c.
#38
My Feedback: (55)
And I can guran-damn-tee you that I do know "jack" about a jet engine. Nor have I ever needed a mech to come start the engine for me. Good grief...
Sluggo
EDIT: Just to make sure, I decided to look again. Yep, there on the back of my "ticket": B-757; B-767; B-777 (in addition to DC-9 and A-320)
(Apologies to OP for off-topic post, but blatant misinformation from SU35 needed to be corrected)
Last edited by VF84sluggo; 05-29-2014 at 05:27 PM.
#39
My Feedback: (21)
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Apple River IL
Posts: 951
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Way big ditto VFSluggo...
"Damn good one too"! Really, I mean really! Allegedly engaged? Like you had your arss in the hot seat right? That's a clueless and disrespectful comment (the entire post) that at the very, the very least, kept you busy during your military service. Which by the way, I thank you for, at least I think I do.........
hook
Though I might have only two type ratings, one starting with a D the other a S, I earned em dude.
Apologies to the OP too, but....
"Damn good one too"! Really, I mean really! Allegedly engaged? Like you had your arss in the hot seat right? That's a clueless and disrespectful comment (the entire post) that at the very, the very least, kept you busy during your military service. Which by the way, I thank you for, at least I think I do.........
hook
Though I might have only two type ratings, one starting with a D the other a S, I earned em dude.
Apologies to the OP too, but....
Last edited by hook57; 05-29-2014 at 05:52 PM.
#40
My Feedback: (55)
Thanks much, Hook!
Indeed, the "allegedly engaged" comment, as well as that whole post, was sheer nonsense, blatantly disrespectful, smacks of jealousy, and is indicative of an inferiority complex. I didn't even want to dignify it with a rebuttal, it was so imbecilic.
And you are dadgum right: those type ratings you hold are definitely earned! Kudos to you.
Indeed, the "allegedly engaged" comment, as well as that whole post, was sheer nonsense, blatantly disrespectful, smacks of jealousy, and is indicative of an inferiority complex. I didn't even want to dignify it with a rebuttal, it was so imbecilic.
And you are dadgum right: those type ratings you hold are definitely earned! Kudos to you.
Last edited by VF84sluggo; 05-29-2014 at 06:03 PM.
#41
My Feedback: (11)
Well I stand corrected on the B-, I never heard of a b-757 I though it might be bomber.
The "allegedly engaged" comment, is meant that at the time, it could not be denied nor confirmed they were in fact engaged. No idea why that is offensive.
And BTW, I dont know how many pilots got mad at me after I flipped a switch so they could go fly. Dont worry, I am used to it. I always loved flying out to a remote base to for a "maintenance issue", well I guess you can call it that. Those bleed air switches are tricky.
And I am curious, were you in the guard/reserves? And what did you fly?
The "allegedly engaged" comment, is meant that at the time, it could not be denied nor confirmed they were in fact engaged. No idea why that is offensive.
And BTW, I dont know how many pilots got mad at me after I flipped a switch so they could go fly. Dont worry, I am used to it. I always loved flying out to a remote base to for a "maintenance issue", well I guess you can call it that. Those bleed air switches are tricky.
And I am curious, were you in the guard/reserves? And what did you fly?
#43
My Feedback: (21)
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Apple River IL
Posts: 951
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Well I stand corrected on the B-, I never heard of a b-757 I though it might be bomber.
The "allegedly engaged" comment, is meant that at the time, it could not be denied nor confirmed they were in fact engaged. No idea why that is offensive.
And BTW, I dont know how many pilots got mad at me after I flipped a switch so they could go fly. Dont worry, I am used to it. I always loved flying out to a remote base to for a "maintenance issue", well I guess you can call it that. Those bleed air switches are tricky.
And I am curious, were you in the guard/reserves? And what did you fly?
The "allegedly engaged" comment, is meant that at the time, it could not be denied nor confirmed they were in fact engaged. No idea why that is offensive.
And BTW, I dont know how many pilots got mad at me after I flipped a switch so they could go fly. Dont worry, I am used to it. I always loved flying out to a remote base to for a "maintenance issue", well I guess you can call it that. Those bleed air switches are tricky.
And I am curious, were you in the guard/reserves? And what did you fly?
hook
#47
My Feedback: (54)
Sluggo and Hook! Thanks for your support and education, as we have seen, some are lacking on here. I knew I have been retired for fifteen years, and knew I was getting older, but when someone has to look up what I used to fly, now I feel really old!! LOL>>>>>>>
Wayne, OP, sorry we got off of subject, but misinformation needs corrected. In closing, the easier you make it on yourself to change out the engines, the more you will enjoy the hobby. As I said earlier, I swapped an engine between two jets for a few years. Just have two complete set ups in both jets, so that all you have to do is 4 bolts, and the plugs and fuel line(s) on the engine. Keep the dirty side down! Dan
Wayne, OP, sorry we got off of subject, but misinformation needs corrected. In closing, the easier you make it on yourself to change out the engines, the more you will enjoy the hobby. As I said earlier, I swapped an engine between two jets for a few years. Just have two complete set ups in both jets, so that all you have to do is 4 bolts, and the plugs and fuel line(s) on the engine. Keep the dirty side down! Dan
#49
My Feedback: (167)
It doesn't have to be the RX or RXI versions. Jetcat has had an internal chip inside the engine for quite a few years now. It was done originally to assist with warranty purposes and allow Jetcat to track time on engines (not on ECU's). This began with either the SE or the SX versions; I don't remember for sure. Anyway from those versions forward you can simply swap the turbine by removing four bolts and unplugging the fuel & electric lines from the front of the turbine and the time logged goes with the turbine. You do not need to change the ECU's, just make sure you have selected the correct turbine program for your engine in the other ECU. It also will have no effect on the startup when changing only the engine. I have done this many times over the years. They are plug & play.
#50
My Feedback: (54)
It doesn't have to be the RX or RXI versions. Jetcat has had an internal chip inside the engine for quite a few years now. It was done originally to assist with warranty purposes and allow Jetcat to track time on engines (not on ECU's). This began with either the SE or the SX versions; I don't remember for sure. Anyway from those versions forward you can simply swap the turbine by removing four bolts and unplugging the fuel & electric lines from the front of the turbine and the time logged goes with the turbine. You do not need to change the ECU's, just make sure you have selected the correct turbine program for your engine in the other ECU. It also will have no effect on the startup when changing only the engine. I have done this many times over the years. They are plug & play.