Engine Fires...
#26
RE: Engine Fires...
Personally I would be very careful with that technique. As long as you are on the ball it is fine but if you are a bit slow and open the tap a bit late you risk an overtemp.
As Pete says, the ECU shouldn't pump fuel if the gas doesn't raise the temp beyond a pre-set limit. If the gas doesn't light, the fuel shouldn't flow.
As Pete says, the ECU shouldn't pump fuel if the gas doesn't raise the temp beyond a pre-set limit. If the gas doesn't light, the fuel shouldn't flow.
#28
RE: Engine Fires...
ORIGINAL: siclick33
Personally I would be very careful with that technique. As long as you are on the ball it is fine but if you are a bit slow and open the tap a bit late you risk an overtemp.
As Pete says, the ECU shouldn't pump fuel if the gas doesn't raise the temp beyond a pre-set limit. If the gas doesn't light, the fuel shouldn't flow.
Personally I would be very careful with that technique. As long as you are on the ball it is fine but if you are a bit slow and open the tap a bit late you risk an overtemp.
As Pete says, the ECU shouldn't pump fuel if the gas doesn't raise the temp beyond a pre-set limit. If the gas doesn't light, the fuel shouldn't flow.
#29
My Feedback: (106)
RE: Engine Fires...
Pete, The Kero solenoid would still open but it don't know that you have the manual valve off. All the ECU wants to see is that the solenoid did open. It's up to you if you have the manual valve open or closed. It all happens in a matter of a Sec or a little more. Your fuel line is full and when you cut the valve on yourself it's right there in your turbine. Now-I don't know if every ECU is like mine. Mine is a modellbau. Your ECU is not going to send a fuel pump on Sig until it sees the right EGT. The gas ramp up does that. It has never failed on mine. Try it sometimes. Put a valve inbetween your solenoid and the turbine and don't cut it on intil you hear the gas light off, then cut the valve on. I have never had a hot or wet start. if you miss the cue and the jet-A don't make it to the combustion chamber than your RPMs and EGT tells the ECU not to cut on the fuel Solenoid. It's fast matter of timing. Your cue to hit the valve is the gas pop. Let me know how it works for you.
Hooker
Hooker
#30
My Feedback: (28)
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Heath,
TX
Posts: 3,886
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Engine Fires...
ORIGINAL: causeitflies
And, if you forget to open the fuel shut-off valve before attempting a start, which I've never done [sm=red_smile.gif], immediately abort the start. If you open it after the pump has started the ramp and is now trying even harder to build up pressure, and suddenly release it, you are sure to get flames and an over temp with the sudden dump of fuel.
ORIGINAL: siclick33
Personally I would be very careful with that technique. As long as you are on the ball it is fine but if you are a bit slow and open the tap a bit late you risk an overtemp.
As Pete says, the ECU shouldn't pump fuel if the gas doesn't raise the temp beyond a pre-set limit. If the gas doesn't light, the fuel shouldn't flow.
Personally I would be very careful with that technique. As long as you are on the ball it is fine but if you are a bit slow and open the tap a bit late you risk an overtemp.
As Pete says, the ECU shouldn't pump fuel if the gas doesn't raise the temp beyond a pre-set limit. If the gas doesn't light, the fuel shouldn't flow.
I have never done that either
#31
Senior Member
My Feedback: (21)
RE: Engine Fires...
ORIGINAL: georbeckha
I had a little flame problem this past weekend...
Flames were orange/transparent (Hard to see)
The ECU measured the last temp as 1045 degree centigrade (Well over 2000 Fahrenheit) when the normal full power operating temp should read no more than 600 F
This was not caused at engine startup by the way. this was after about 2 minutes into the flight. Looking at the Elevator and rudder servo leads I think I'm lucky to get it back in one piece (So to speak)
I had a little flame problem this past weekend...
Flames were orange/transparent (Hard to see)
The ECU measured the last temp as 1045 degree centigrade (Well over 2000 Fahrenheit) when the normal full power operating temp should read no more than 600 F
This was not caused at engine startup by the way. this was after about 2 minutes into the flight. Looking at the Elevator and rudder servo leads I think I'm lucky to get it back in one piece (So to speak)
What were the results after talking with the folks at Jetcat? Are you still running your fuel pump filter on its side like in the pictures of the Shock Jet? I think they recommend mounting it vertical to eliminate any air that could get trapped. I am interested in learning what is causing your overspead and overtemp problems.
MACE
#32
Senior Member
My Feedback: (12)
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Swartz Creek,
MI
Posts: 212
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Engine Fires...
Mace,
The first time they said that the speed sensor magnets got demagnetized so it didn't know exactly how fast the engine was running. This caused the shaft to bend and the result was the destruction of the engine, flames and a little singing of the wood.
The pictures up there are of the rebuilt engine doing pretty much the same thing, but this time the flames took hold.
In the picture attached here you can see a white patch in the middle of the runway behind the model. that is where it come to rest. Probably my best landing job so far with the ShockJet. It's amazing considering I was yelling to the peanut gallery that there was a fire and they just sat there watching (They say they didn't hear me) and I was watching the flames eating my plane.
The Filter I have in line was actually standing upright. I think it got twisted around when the fuel line got pulled tight when the engine seized and torqued around.
George
The first time they said that the speed sensor magnets got demagnetized so it didn't know exactly how fast the engine was running. This caused the shaft to bend and the result was the destruction of the engine, flames and a little singing of the wood.
The pictures up there are of the rebuilt engine doing pretty much the same thing, but this time the flames took hold.
In the picture attached here you can see a white patch in the middle of the runway behind the model. that is where it come to rest. Probably my best landing job so far with the ShockJet. It's amazing considering I was yelling to the peanut gallery that there was a fire and they just sat there watching (They say they didn't hear me) and I was watching the flames eating my plane.
The Filter I have in line was actually standing upright. I think it got twisted around when the fuel line got pulled tight when the engine seized and torqued around.
George
ORIGINAL: Mace
georbeckha
What were the results after talking with the folks at Jetcat? Are you still running your fuel pump filter on its side like in the pictures of the Shock Jet? I think they recommend mounting it vertical to eliminate any air that could get trapped. I am interested in learning what is causing your overspead and overtemp problems.
MACE
ORIGINAL: georbeckha
I had a little flame problem this past weekend...
Flames were orange/transparent (Hard to see)
The ECU measured the last temp as 1045 degree centigrade (Well over 2000 Fahrenheit) when the normal full power operating temp should read no more than 600 F
This was not caused at engine startup by the way. this was after about 2 minutes into the flight. Looking at the Elevator and rudder servo leads I think I'm lucky to get it back in one piece (So to speak)
I had a little flame problem this past weekend...
Flames were orange/transparent (Hard to see)
The ECU measured the last temp as 1045 degree centigrade (Well over 2000 Fahrenheit) when the normal full power operating temp should read no more than 600 F
This was not caused at engine startup by the way. this was after about 2 minutes into the flight. Looking at the Elevator and rudder servo leads I think I'm lucky to get it back in one piece (So to speak)
What were the results after talking with the folks at Jetcat? Are you still running your fuel pump filter on its side like in the pictures of the Shock Jet? I think they recommend mounting it vertical to eliminate any air that could get trapped. I am interested in learning what is causing your overspead and overtemp problems.
MACE
#35
RE: Engine Fires...
You should have had one of these.... [link]http://www.speedfreaks.net.au/index.php?page=shop.product_details&category_id=10&flypage=flypage.tpl&product_id=103&option=com_virtuemart&Itemid=1[/link]
#37
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2006
Location: East Providence, RI
Posts: 1,644
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Engine Fires...
Do any of you use any form of heat protection on the inside of the fuse where the thrust nozzle is? I would imagine the area around the nozzle and tailpipe gap must be the hottest. I used some heat tape over my servo leads.
Thanks! Pete
Thanks! Pete
#39
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2006
Location: East Providence, RI
Posts: 1,644
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Engine Fires...
I should have asked if it is even necessary to prep the fuse for heat from the turbine. Wouldn't something like that be provided in the ARF if it was an issue?
Thanks! Pete
Thanks! Pete
#41
My Feedback: (4)
RE: Engine Fires...
The problem with putting the shut off valve between the UAT and the pump is that the valve can act as a restriction which the pump must overcome when the turbine is running in normal operation. The restriction can lead to cavitation and bubbles being created in the fuel line to the turbine. The small Tetra valve provided with JetCat engines certainly is a restriction, but it is installed on the 4mm output side of the pump. A 6mm Festo 1/4 turn ball valve provides little restriction and can be installed on the inlet (suction) side of the pump. However, make sure that the Festo seals properly as any leaks will result in air being drawn into the suction line to the pump.
If I had to shut down the turbine due to a fire, I would do it using the transmitter shutoff (closes both the fuel solonoids and kills power to the ECU) rather than reaching into a plane that is on fire and I may or may not be able to see the flame in/around the shutoff valve. Of course, but this time I've already given it a shot from the extinguisher.
If I had to shut down the turbine due to a fire, I would do it using the transmitter shutoff (closes both the fuel solonoids and kills power to the ECU) rather than reaching into a plane that is on fire and I may or may not be able to see the flame in/around the shutoff valve. Of course, but this time I've already given it a shot from the extinguisher.
#42
My Feedback: (57)
RE: Engine Fires...
Good call Jim!
That's probably why JetCat recommends their valve after the pump. I always use the 6mm Festo ball-valve between the UAT and pump thus providing the least restriction. There is already a 6mm line coming from the UAT and some pumps already have the larger diameter inlet nipple, so it's a very easy set-up. And yes, make sure the line is fully seated in ALL Festos.
That's probably why JetCat recommends their valve after the pump. I always use the 6mm Festo ball-valve between the UAT and pump thus providing the least restriction. There is already a 6mm line coming from the UAT and some pumps already have the larger diameter inlet nipple, so it's a very easy set-up. And yes, make sure the line is fully seated in ALL Festos.
#43
RE: Engine Fires...
If I had to shut down the turbine due to a fire, I would do it using the transmitter shutoff (closes both the fuel solonoids and kills power to the ECU) rather than reaching into a plane that is on fire
#44
My Feedback: (4)
RE: Engine Fires...
ORIGINAL: siclick33
So would I!!. The 2 reasons for the manual valve, as far as I can see, is that you prevent the engine being flooded when refuelling and so that you have the means to shut off the engine following some form of ECU failure that leaves the pump running. It is a last resort shutoff only if the TX shutoff doesn't work.
So would I!!. The 2 reasons for the manual valve, as far as I can see, is that you prevent the engine being flooded when refuelling and so that you have the means to shut off the engine following some form of ECU failure that leaves the pump running. It is a last resort shutoff only if the TX shutoff doesn't work.
Assuming that the solonoid valve doesn't leak through, that would leave only one reason for the manual shutoff, it is the last resort.
Correct me if I'm wrong here, but I think the AMA requirement for a shutoff valve is met by the solonoid valve and there is no requirement to ALSO have a manual valve. Either way, I always install one (just in case) and it is ALWAYS closed when I refuel.
#45
My Feedback: (57)
RE: Engine Fires...
This straight from the AMA 510-A document:
8. ... The fuel system shall have two fuel shut-off provisions, one of which is manual and the other one must be remotely operated. An ECU operated shut down is compliant as a remote shut-off if it closes with loss of power.
If the ECU is compromised, it might not have the ability to de-energize the fuel solenoid. Also, as most of us have found out, the solenoid by itself won't necessarily prevent fuel from being pushed passed it and into the turbine while fueling.
8. ... The fuel system shall have two fuel shut-off provisions, one of which is manual and the other one must be remotely operated. An ECU operated shut down is compliant as a remote shut-off if it closes with loss of power.
If the ECU is compromised, it might not have the ability to de-energize the fuel solenoid. Also, as most of us have found out, the solenoid by itself won't necessarily prevent fuel from being pushed passed it and into the turbine while fueling.
#46
RE: Engine Fires...
The Australian rules for turbines require a radio controlled method of shutting the turbine down independant of the ECU as well as a manual shut off valve.
I use this arrangement to do both jobs.
The servo is also set up with the failsafe to shut the fuel valve.- John.
I use this arrangement to do both jobs.
The servo is also set up with the failsafe to shut the fuel valve.- John.
#49
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Newcastle, UNITED KINGDOM
Posts: 546
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: Engine Fires...
ORIGINAL: Boomerang1
The Australian rules for turbines require a radio controlled method of shutting the turbine down independant of the ECU as well as a manual shut off valve.
I use this arrangement to do both jobs.
The servo is also set up with the failsafe to shut the fuel valve.- John.
The Australian rules for turbines require a radio controlled method of shutting the turbine down independant of the ECU as well as a manual shut off valve.
I use this arrangement to do both jobs.
The servo is also set up with the failsafe to shut the fuel valve.- John.
Its the same in the UK and most of Europe. I use a manual festo valve before the turbine. On my on TX either pulling the trim down or loss of signal and switching off the fadec will kill the pump. In addition, I use a one way switch to the pumps power lead, so by servo in the air or by hand on start up in the pits, I can kill the the pumps power instantly. The switch is one way to be manually reset only. It looks as if this type of setup might have saved some models becoming crisp and well done.
Paul
#50
RE: Engine Fires...
ORIGINAL: Boomerang1
The Australian rules for turbines require a radio controlled method of shutting the turbine down independant of the ECU as well as a manual shut off valve.
I use this arrangement to do both jobs.
The servo is also set up with the failsafe to shut the fuel valve.- John.
The Australian rules for turbines require a radio controlled method of shutting the turbine down independant of the ECU as well as a manual shut off valve.
I use this arrangement to do both jobs.
The servo is also set up with the failsafe to shut the fuel valve.- John.
Its the same in the UK and most of Europe.