Graupner Extra 300
#76
Member
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 42
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Galway / Ireland
Hi,
I have what may seem like a silly question for those who have fitted the braces.
Should I tighten the braces so that I exert pressure on the Stabilizer down wards (ie holding it down ) or push the braces out so that I exert pressure up (pushing the stab up).
I do presume it's down unless the stab breaks in outside loop type moves but I'd like to check.
Thanks again,
Rob
I have what may seem like a silly question for those who have fitted the braces.
Should I tighten the braces so that I exert pressure on the Stabilizer down wards (ie holding it down ) or push the braces out so that I exert pressure up (pushing the stab up).
I do presume it's down unless the stab breaks in outside loop type moves but I'd like to check.
Thanks again,
Rob
#77
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 2,162
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Los Angeles,
CA
Originally posted by Irish Rob
Hi,
I have what may seem like a silly question for those who have fitted the braces.
Should I tighten the braces so that I exert pressure on the Stabilizer down wards (ie holding it down ) or push the braces out so that I exert pressure up (pushing the stab up).
I do presume it's down unless the stab breaks in outside loop type moves but I'd like to check.
Thanks again,
Rob
Hi,
I have what may seem like a silly question for those who have fitted the braces.
Should I tighten the braces so that I exert pressure on the Stabilizer down wards (ie holding it down ) or push the braces out so that I exert pressure up (pushing the stab up).
I do presume it's down unless the stab breaks in outside loop type moves but I'd like to check.
Thanks again,
Rob
I put braces on mine, and used the logic that they are there to provide support to the stab from more than just the middle. It's the fact that the strength is in the shape of an unsupported cantilever that might cause the breakages. Supporting at another point as well will dramatically increase the strength.
I would suggest you set it up with no tension in any direction, and let the strain provide the direction of the support when the stab tries to bend.
Just my 2c (or 2p) worth!
-David C.
#79
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 2,162
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Los Angeles,
CA
Originally posted by Irish Rob
Now why didn't I think of that !
Thanks David !
BTW how do you find it ?
Now why didn't I think of that !
Thanks David !
BTW how do you find it ?
So far <fingers crossed> I haven't had anything at all go wrong with the tail end of the plane, in spite of doing some pretty stressful flying (to me, and the plane!).
I have had an aileron servos come adrift (the mounting plate broke, and has now been really well epoxied!) but that's another story.
A great plane to fly though. Very graceful.
-David C.
#80
Junior Member
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 23
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Milton Freewater,
OR
I recieved my Extra 300 several months ago and had it built within a week. Quality was excellent. Hobby Lobby sent me the tailplane bracing a week later.
My question is regarding the balance point for the CG. I measured in both inches and metric and still had to add over 12 ozs of lead to the nose in order to get a good balance.
Does anyone out there have some data as to where the exact balance point is and how much weight (if any) was required. I am using an OS 60H and a standard size radio mounted at the specified location.
I'm hesitant to fly the plane at this time until I get the CG question resolved.
Any advice would be of great help.
HAL
My question is regarding the balance point for the CG. I measured in both inches and metric and still had to add over 12 ozs of lead to the nose in order to get a good balance.
Does anyone out there have some data as to where the exact balance point is and how much weight (if any) was required. I am using an OS 60H and a standard size radio mounted at the specified location.
I'm hesitant to fly the plane at this time until I get the CG question resolved.
Any advice would be of great help.
HAL
#81
Senior Member
My Feedback: (4)
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 105
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: MN
I thought I'd help ya out so I just put mine on my great planes balancer and got 103-104 mm or 4- 3/16" at this setting it should perform real well for you. the directions called for 98mm but I found this to be WAY to extreme-The first time I took mine out it was real sensitive to any tail input (rudder or elevator) so its best to start with it further back and with relativley small movement in the tail (low rates) to start, Especially with the elevator. I thought the elevator looked to be a little small before I flew this bird but found it to be just fine, And if anything kind of sensitive. So I rebalanced it a tiny bit foward and set my linkages to low rates and she handles real nice now! mabey I'll move it a bit back down the road after I become more familiar with this plane but for now this is the best point for balancing for easy going with her!!
I am flying with a O.S. .91fx and have tons of power and have'nt leaned the motor yet ( still breaking it in) I was able to pull off a 'very clean' knife edge with it on my last flight
and greased the landings !! I think you'll like it. but just remember to keep it on low rates to begin with.--- Good luck!!
P.S. She tends to want to snap on high rates (with a little extra dialed in)
Also all my balancing is done where the wing meets the fuslage. Hope this helps!!
I am flying with a O.S. .91fx and have tons of power and have'nt leaned the motor yet ( still breaking it in) I was able to pull off a 'very clean' knife edge with it on my last flight
and greased the landings !! I think you'll like it. but just remember to keep it on low rates to begin with.--- Good luck!! P.S. She tends to want to snap on high rates (with a little extra dialed in)
Also all my balancing is done where the wing meets the fuslage. Hope this helps!!
#82
Junior Member
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 23
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Milton Freewater,
OR
Thanks for the input . My setup is about 1/4" farther forward than yours which would account for most of the extra weight required. I'll try your setup. As for the low rate suggestion on the elevator - I agree. I've set up my Xmitter for dual rates with low input settings.
Thanks again. I'll let you know how it turns out.
HAL
Thanks again. I'll let you know how it turns out.
HAL
#83
Member
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 42
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Galway / Ireland
Has anyone else found the tank on this to be too small ?
I'm only getting 4mins, although the engine is new and I'm running it a bit rich.
I am ordering a DUBro 12oz tank that I will have to widen the opening for.
Thing is I'm worried the extra weight will mess up the balance ????
As for everything else it's fantastic !
My friend (An accomplished F3a pilot ) is so impressed he's talking of having one too!
Rob
I'm only getting 4mins, although the engine is new and I'm running it a bit rich.
I am ordering a DUBro 12oz tank that I will have to widen the opening for.
Thing is I'm worried the extra weight will mess up the balance ????
As for everything else it's fantastic !
My friend (An accomplished F3a pilot ) is so impressed he's talking of having one too!
Rob
#84
Junior Member
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 3
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Thomasville,
NC
Well on the third trip to the field gthe stab. broke off and we had the braces. went to my hobby store and hobby lobby is sending out a stab and rudder we where lucky came down in some corn so it did not hit as hard. Still love the plane lets see if this stab is different. May have to build one my self if not. Any one know how to strengthen it besides the flying wires. Our stab came off on a fly by.
#85
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 131
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: kuressaare, ESTONIA
hi everybody
silly but still question that hasn`t been asked here.
In this kit can be found also tiny aluminum plate with holes predrilled (seems that it can be broken apart. There is different one for stab). Couldn`t find a place to match it in.
Second question, there are plenty of the rubberbands. What for are these??
Crow
silly but still question that hasn`t been asked here.
In this kit can be found also tiny aluminum plate with holes predrilled (seems that it can be broken apart. There is different one for stab). Couldn`t find a place to match it in.
Second question, there are plenty of the rubberbands. What for are these??
Crow
#86
Originally posted by crow
hi everybody
silly but still question that hasn`t been asked here.
In this kit can be found also tiny aluminum plate with holes predrilled (seems that it can be broken apart. There is different one for stab). Couldn`t find a place to match it in.
Crow
hi everybody
silly but still question that hasn`t been asked here.
In this kit can be found also tiny aluminum plate with holes predrilled (seems that it can be broken apart. There is different one for stab). Couldn`t find a place to match it in.
Crow
Second question, there are plenty of the rubberbands. What for are these??
if the stabilazor did not hold you can hold the pieces together
with the rubberbands to bring it to the BBQ
sorry could not help myself
Crow [/B][/QUOTE]
#88
Member
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 42
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Galway / Ireland
Crow,
I found these too.
I disgarded the pre-drilled one as I think it was the first version of an upgrade for the stab. that was in the kit.
(It's also more evidence that the kit is made by Seagull , but thats for another day !)
Sandor could be right about the rubber bands !
Rob
I found these too.
I disgarded the pre-drilled one as I think it was the first version of an upgrade for the stab. that was in the kit.
(It's also more evidence that the kit is made by Seagull , but thats for another day !)
Sandor could be right about the rubber bands !
Rob
#91
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 131
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: kuressaare, ESTONIA
it is my first ARF,
as far as i understand the ARF means that you open the box and put a thing together not first go to buy screws.
Strange, the manufacturer does a great job, but on the same time he can`t put a right sized screws in the box, laugh or cry.
Don`t get me wrong, i`m not an grumbler, anyhow i like this plane a lot.
as far as i understand the ARF means that you open the box and put a thing together not first go to buy screws.
Strange, the manufacturer does a great job, but on the same time he can`t put a right sized screws in the box, laugh or cry.
Don`t get me wrong, i`m not an grumbler, anyhow i like this plane a lot.
#92
Member
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 42
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Galway / Ireland
You like it now,
Wait till you fly it you'll love it!
How's the weather in Estonia for this hobby ?
It's been even wetter than usual here since I built my model and have had little or no flying time on it.
Wait till you fly it you'll love it!
How's the weather in Estonia for this hobby ?
It's been even wetter than usual here since I built my model and have had little or no flying time on it.
#93
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 131
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: kuressaare, ESTONIA
the weatherguy is on modelers side, has been 25 deg heat and no rain at all. Usually 2mph wind. Just perfect!!
Hopfully stays so to the end of summer.
Crow
Hopfully stays so to the end of summer.
Crow
#94
Member
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 42
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Galway / Ireland
Could you send him over here pls !
15 mph winds at least and we have to get out between the showers if at all. ( And this is height of summer !).
What engine you going to use on that bird !
Rob
15 mph winds at least and we have to get out between the showers if at all. ( And this is height of summer !).
What engine you going to use on that bird !
Rob
#95
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 131
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: kuressaare, ESTONIA
61, some kind of chinese masterpiece
. Too impatient to wait for three weeks to get better one.
Heard that 61 could have little less power than needed to do aerobatic manuvers?!
Still on question came up: how far is best place for a CG from wing leadingedge
Crow
. Too impatient to wait for three weeks to get better one.Heard that 61 could have little less power than needed to do aerobatic manuvers?!
Still on question came up: how far is best place for a CG from wing leadingedge
Crow
#96
Member
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 42
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Galway / Ireland
Due to beautifull Irish summer I havn't had very much time flying mine to do to much acro stuff so I wouldn't know if yours is underpowered, sorry.
CG in mine is a little back 10 mm from recommended (98mm I think!)
My F3a flying friend reckons it's a bit forward for serious acrobatics at that.
Speaking of waiting for parts, where do you get yours from ?
Sorry if I'm being nosey
CG in mine is a little back 10 mm from recommended (98mm I think!)
My F3a flying friend reckons it's a bit forward for serious acrobatics at that.
Speaking of waiting for parts, where do you get yours from ?
Sorry if I'm being nosey
#97
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 131
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: kuressaare, ESTONIA
We have one hobby shop for hole country, but it is quite well equiped. There are also some planes and engines but mostly bigger stuff has to be ordered from graupner or robbe or simprop.
Crow
Crow
#98
Member
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 42
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Galway / Ireland
One shop wow!
Because it's German it was cheaper to buy the Extra there and ship.
I presume you'll be testing it out this weekend, have fun !!
(And send us some good weather )
Rob
Because it's German it was cheaper to buy the Extra there and ship.
I presume you'll be testing it out this weekend, have fun !!
(And send us some good weather )
Rob
#100
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 131
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: kuressaare, ESTONIA
ok, didn`t go that well. It is a quite fast plane. Ended up with crash. Don`t belive it was all my fault, engine stoped in the air. Tried to make a turn and land but plane went into spin, wasn`t much left to do.
It is repairable, takes two days to fix.
What amazed me was that the extra is so easy to go into spin. Could the problem be in CG, it was bit aft.
Funny was that when i removed the cover i found with regular pen written signature on piece between main spars. Have somebody else found something like this? Does the builder sign his work?
put pic soon.
Crow
one more thing. Someone had said the landing gear plate comes off easely not destroying the whole plane. It is true,but bad thing is that when the wheelpants bending back they actually hit the wing and leave remarkable holes in it. Save fuse, loose wing.
Also noticed that placeing the battery behind servos, up on the cockpit floor is not a good idea. Mine got loose and went through everything up to nose, breaking servo plat etc.
It is repairable, takes two days to fix.
What amazed me was that the extra is so easy to go into spin. Could the problem be in CG, it was bit aft.
Funny was that when i removed the cover i found with regular pen written signature on piece between main spars. Have somebody else found something like this? Does the builder sign his work?
put pic soon.
Crow
one more thing. Someone had said the landing gear plate comes off easely not destroying the whole plane. It is true,but bad thing is that when the wheelpants bending back they actually hit the wing and leave remarkable holes in it. Save fuse, loose wing.
Also noticed that placeing the battery behind servos, up on the cockpit floor is not a good idea. Mine got loose and went through everything up to nose, breaking servo plat etc.



