What the heck is the white dot??
#1
Thread Starter

Joined: May 2006
Posts: 1,644
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: East Providence, RI
I was just surfing FEJ's and there is a notice about the 6014FS having a white dot...It says if there is not white dot send it in for an upgrade??? What the hell?
I just bought 2 6014FS's in the last month from tower. Neither of them have a white dot, Nor does the one in my 16 that was included with my 12FG i bought in November. I have a dozen flights on them between my 16 and 310 and they feel just fine. What is going on?
Sorry if this has already been posted but I just saw it and it made me really nervous..
Pete
I just bought 2 6014FS's in the last month from tower. Neither of them have a white dot, Nor does the one in my 16 that was included with my 12FG i bought in November. I have a dozen flights on them between my 16 and 310 and they feel just fine. What is going on?
Sorry if this has already been posted but I just saw it and it made me really nervous..
Pete
#2
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 328
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: zonhoven, BELGIUM
The RX with the dot are not/less sensible for heat. The first FASST RX's could not work properly when exposed to heat (> 50°C).
I think..
I think..
#6

there was some talk amungst the Futaba people in the know who said the dots only meant the QA check was completed on the receiver. i don't own any Futaba myself, but i do allot of building for others and some of the newer receivers have had white dots, some gold.
#10
ORIGINAL: siclick33
Koeniboy,
Have you actually heard that from Futaba?
Koeniboy,
Have you actually heard that from Futaba?
Hobbico who is the Futaba repair center here in the USA claims to
know nothing about the dots or the heat related issues, However
many people have done their own test and have found that the
non dot receivers will sometime shut down when they become a
little hot while the dotted receivers can take a lot more heat.
#11
You want the whole story ? Check this post if you have patience to read through it http://www.flyinggiants.com/forums/f...ggestions.html
Fill the missing info of the link with flying - giants . com
Fill the missing info of the link with flying - giants . com
#14

My Feedback: (44)
The dotted version took care of more than just heat issues, they also adjusted the drive levels (signal levels) to the servos.
See post #2045 of the following thread for photos
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_61...82/key_/tm.htm
See post #24 of the following thread for the drive levels of the dotted version, the non dotted version will cause problems if you use Hi-Tec digital servos or certain other ancillary devices like sequencers, or valves, a simple line driver (amplifier) like the one sold by electrodynamics will cure any problems with drive levels of the non dotted receiver.
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_87...tm.htm#8750838
See post #2045 of the following thread for photos
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_61...82/key_/tm.htm
See post #24 of the following thread for the drive levels of the dotted version, the non dotted version will cause problems if you use Hi-Tec digital servos or certain other ancillary devices like sequencers, or valves, a simple line driver (amplifier) like the one sold by electrodynamics will cure any problems with drive levels of the non dotted receiver.
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_87...tm.htm#8750838
#15
Thread Starter

Joined: May 2006
Posts: 1,644
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: East Providence, RI
Im running all Digital Hitecs on my non-dotted version and everything has been uneventful..
Always something..[:@]
Pete
Always something..[:@]
Pete
#16
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 958
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Miramar,
FL
Pete,
The issue was with one or two old Hitec digital servos, and Hitec is fixing them for free.
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_82..._1/key_/tm.htm
Doug.
The issue was with one or two old Hitec digital servos, and Hitec is fixing them for free.
http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_82..._1/key_/tm.htm
Doug.
#17

My Feedback: (44)
There is a quick test to see if your receiver is the new version,or old version (I just got done checking two receivers for my buddy) connect two Hi-Tec digital's on a Y harness and try it....if it is the old version they will be very unstable.
Even with one servo the signal is very unstable with a hi-Tec digital connected
Photo #1 shows the output of the receiver connected to one H-Tec Servo on the top trace
The bottom trace is the signal through a line driver (amplifier), notice that the signal on the bottom is around 4.8 V where the signal on the top is around 2.8 v
Photo # 2 is with the output of the receiver connected to two Hi-Tec servos, notice that the bottom trace the pulse width is widened (out of compliance)
Photo #3 is the output of the receiver connected just to the line driver, the output of the line driver is connected to two hi-tec digital servos, note there is no more distortion of the signal, and the levels are around 4.8V
Bottom line is I would not trust running any hi-tec digital servos with out using a line driver on the older receiver.
Even with one servo the signal is very unstable with a hi-Tec digital connected
Photo #1 shows the output of the receiver connected to one H-Tec Servo on the top trace
The bottom trace is the signal through a line driver (amplifier), notice that the signal on the bottom is around 4.8 V where the signal on the top is around 2.8 v
Photo # 2 is with the output of the receiver connected to two Hi-Tec servos, notice that the bottom trace the pulse width is widened (out of compliance)
Photo #3 is the output of the receiver connected just to the line driver, the output of the line driver is connected to two hi-tec digital servos, note there is no more distortion of the signal, and the levels are around 4.8V
Bottom line is I would not trust running any hi-tec digital servos with out using a line driver on the older receiver.
#19
My Gold dot has gone, I think it got too hot, but it is working perfectly with 8 digital Hitec servos, two Jetteck valves and a couple of sequencers on it. 
Mike

Mike
#20
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 308
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Johannesburg, SOUTH AFRICA
Welcome to Futaba's All Secret Service Tell-no-one - FASST 
Nothing seems to have been published officially by Futaba. Tests done by an individual on this forum has "confirmed" that the gold dot version would handle temps in excess of 100 degC and the older "non dot" versions would stop working in excess of 70 deg. If you visit the FASST site you will see that they recommend not wrapping the receiver in foam and ensuring sufficient airflow around the receiver to prevent heat build-up. That is why some guys chose to put small fans on the non dot versions.
As stated above as well the low signal voltage issue has also been addressed in the newer "gold dot" version. We have only got gold dot versions over here so I am not too sure if the "white dot" is the same as the "gold dot"? The latest version is the HS which has 6 high speed outputs for digital servos.
I made sure I found some "gold dot" versions for our African sun.
I have not seen anyone locally have issues with the non dot versions in both jets and large scale aircraft.

Nothing seems to have been published officially by Futaba. Tests done by an individual on this forum has "confirmed" that the gold dot version would handle temps in excess of 100 degC and the older "non dot" versions would stop working in excess of 70 deg. If you visit the FASST site you will see that they recommend not wrapping the receiver in foam and ensuring sufficient airflow around the receiver to prevent heat build-up. That is why some guys chose to put small fans on the non dot versions.
As stated above as well the low signal voltage issue has also been addressed in the newer "gold dot" version. We have only got gold dot versions over here so I am not too sure if the "white dot" is the same as the "gold dot"? The latest version is the HS which has 6 high speed outputs for digital servos.
I made sure I found some "gold dot" versions for our African sun.
I have not seen anyone locally have issues with the non dot versions in both jets and large scale aircraft.
#21
As far as I know the only people who had problems with overheating where using the Rx in extreme conditions (Middle East) as far as the low voltage issue I have an FS version in an Elan with all digital servos and it works without problems, none of my airframes use Y leads they can be the source of problems, I also do not use 4 cell AA size 4.8volt batteries to supply my Rx and servo's.
Mike
Mike
#23

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 3,294
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
From: farnborough, , UNITED KINGDOM
I was looking over the pictures of the two Rx's earlier in this thread, is it me or are the components different on the two - look in the area where the two antenna's pass over [&:]
If so is this usual?
marcs
If so is this usual?
marcs
#24
ORIGINAL: airega1
Hey Gonzalo, is that a Smart-Fly setup with the fan?
Hey Gonzalo, is that a Smart-Fly setup with the fan?
I don't think that there are a lot of heat issues in jets since there is a good air flow inside the fuselage, but in IMAC type planes were everything is enclosed, there could be some problems if you leave your plane under the sun even for a short period of time.
According to some test that were done, the temperature at which some of the non-dotted receivers would stop working was very low so why take a risk ? I bought some small fans and installed them on the receivers. Do the fans help ? I don't know....... but at least I have peace of mind knowing that I did take precautions.
http://www3.towerhobbies.com/cgi-bin...?&I=LXMYJ0&P=7
#25
ORIGINAL: BaldEagel
As far as I know the only people who had problems with overheating where using the Rx in extreme conditions (Middle East) as far as the low voltage issue I have an FS version in an Elan with all digital servos and it works without problems, none of my airframes use Y leads they can be the source of problems, I also do not use 4 cell AA size 4.8volt batteries to supply my Rx and servo's.
Mike
As far as I know the only people who had problems with overheating where using the Rx in extreme conditions (Middle East) as far as the low voltage issue I have an FS version in an Elan with all digital servos and it works without problems, none of my airframes use Y leads they can be the source of problems, I also do not use 4 cell AA size 4.8volt batteries to supply my Rx and servo's.
Mike
same way as the dotted one's and others that are currently on the market because more precautions have to be taken in high heat environments and I
would say this is more true for the 608 6014 non dotted receivers.





