GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
#3176
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: atlanta,
GA
Posts: 921
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
Bob I am using a G 62 .I am glad to here it should not be a problem .Never fiber glassed a plane before didnt know how much weight it would add should be able to keep it with in 10 more pounds
#3177
My Feedback: (6)
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
Cimara
I have never glassed a bird eather, and I am reading all I can I have been following several threads but mostly the glassing thing over on Peter Oz's thread T/F P-47 a aother bloody one, along with the mods and his build. I am looking at the klass - kote and west systems, also looking at the water acrlic method, but have not made up my mind as yet. some sware by Hobby - poxy but I am not sure about it, but that is just me.
As for weight from what I have read if you do it right it is little more than plastic. I know the fellows reading this thread can give you better info than I, So we will just have to learn together.
And a G- 62 is a good choice.
Cheers Bob T
Corsair Brotherhood #5
#3180
Senior Member
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
Winston,
I've done a bunch of fiberglass work but never on an RC airplane. I repaired the wing tips on my full Scale Piper P-28 140 Cherokee and when your done it's kind of like when you fill a low spot with putty. Most of the weight is sanded away. I don't know about 1/4 lb. but it surely shouldn't be more than 1/2 lb. unless you make it 1/8" thick. I am going to just use one layer of .75 glass and finishing resin on mine and then fill the rest of the weave with auto spot putty and sand it smooth. Just my method. I've read it works great and is very light.
Barry
I've done a bunch of fiberglass work but never on an RC airplane. I repaired the wing tips on my full Scale Piper P-28 140 Cherokee and when your done it's kind of like when you fill a low spot with putty. Most of the weight is sanded away. I don't know about 1/4 lb. but it surely shouldn't be more than 1/2 lb. unless you make it 1/8" thick. I am going to just use one layer of .75 glass and finishing resin on mine and then fill the rest of the weave with auto spot putty and sand it smooth. Just my method. I've read it works great and is very light.
Barry
#3181
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: atlanta,
GA
Posts: 921
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
Well thats better than what i read in a reveiw online the guy said that paint and glassing would add 3 to 4 pounds .I was planning on using automotive filler primer to fill the weave
#3182
Banned
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Brisbane, Queensland, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 7,744
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
I use automotive acrylic paint. Any paint will add weight very quickly if you are heavy handed. So light coats, just enough to get good colour depth and coverage.
#3183
Banned
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Brisbane, Queensland, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 7,744
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
ORIGINAL: cimara
Well thats better than what i read in a reveiw online the guy said that paint and glassing would add 3 to 4 pounds .I was planning on using automotive filler primer to fill the weave
Well thats better than what i read in a reveiw online the guy said that paint and glassing would add 3 to 4 pounds .I was planning on using automotive filler primer to fill the weave
to fill the weave? Man you are going to add POUNDS that way.
Each to their own.
#3184
Senior Member
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
Peter_OZ,
Automotive red spot putty is very light and won't add POUNDS to the job. Have you ever tried it or are you just guessing. I have read numerous articles about it. It is a very light way to finish the plane. The weave will be filled except after taking all the excess resin off thy cloth there will be a slightly pourous surface. I'm not talking about filling all the weave way into the cloth with putty but just a very thin layer which will then be sanded smooth to the cloth. It will almost all disappear. I think you are just knocking it because you have never tried it before. I have and know what I'm talking about!!! Have you ever done fiberglass repair on a full scale aircraft, I don't think so? I have. It has to meet high standards to be cleared to fly! You do it your way and we will do it our way.
Thanks but no thanks,
Gibbs
Automotive red spot putty is very light and won't add POUNDS to the job. Have you ever tried it or are you just guessing. I have read numerous articles about it. It is a very light way to finish the plane. The weave will be filled except after taking all the excess resin off thy cloth there will be a slightly pourous surface. I'm not talking about filling all the weave way into the cloth with putty but just a very thin layer which will then be sanded smooth to the cloth. It will almost all disappear. I think you are just knocking it because you have never tried it before. I have and know what I'm talking about!!! Have you ever done fiberglass repair on a full scale aircraft, I don't think so? I have. It has to meet high standards to be cleared to fly! You do it your way and we will do it our way.
Thanks but no thanks,
Gibbs
#3185
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: atlanta,
GA
Posts: 921
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
ORIGINAL: Peter_OZ
to fill the weave? Man you are going to add POUNDS that way.
Each to their own.
ORIGINAL: cimara
Well thats better than what i read in a reveiw online the guy said that paint and glassing would add 3 to 4 pounds .I was planning on using automotive filler primer to fill the weave
Well thats better than what i read in a reveiw online the guy said that paint and glassing would add 3 to 4 pounds .I was planning on using automotive filler primer to fill the weave
to fill the weave? Man you are going to add POUNDS that way.
Each to their own.
#3187
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
Now that you guys have gotten all riled up, you may want to sit back and hope Peter actually replies. He's been one of my mentors over the past couple of years, and I'm convinced that he knows what he's talking about.
Tom
Tom
#3189
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: atlanta,
GA
Posts: 921
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
I didnt say he didnt have great info and if you all would look there is a smlily face at the end of my statment .I am here trying to learn
#3190
Senior Member
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
Tom And Bob,
I said what I know and feel and won't take it back. I'm not new to this building RC planes thing and I don't need someone saying something that in my opinion isn't true. Spot putty weighs less than resin and if you can tell me otherwise I'll listen. I've worked with fiberglass for over 30 years and think I should know what I'm talking about. Plus the use of all caps as he started is a form of yelling and letting you know he thinks you don't know anything. I hope you will still consider me a friend and Pete too. I just speak my mind. This after all is the land of the free and freedom of speach. What I said should only make him prove me wrong and that will come by weighing each plane when done.
Best Regards,
Barry
I said what I know and feel and won't take it back. I'm not new to this building RC planes thing and I don't need someone saying something that in my opinion isn't true. Spot putty weighs less than resin and if you can tell me otherwise I'll listen. I've worked with fiberglass for over 30 years and think I should know what I'm talking about. Plus the use of all caps as he started is a form of yelling and letting you know he thinks you don't know anything. I hope you will still consider me a friend and Pete too. I just speak my mind. This after all is the land of the free and freedom of speach. What I said should only make him prove me wrong and that will come by weighing each plane when done.
Best Regards,
Barry
#3191
Senior Member
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: saginaw,
MI
Posts: 2,761
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
barry you are right. i use it to fill the weave. some of these guys think they are experts well that isnt always the case! the filler is mistley sanded away and the initial primer coats are inteded to find imperfections. my p-47 is 28 lbs and a g-45 flys her. shes not a floater bit warbirds were not.
tell the guys giving you trouble to stick with h-9 sport birds and crudokote!
tell the guys giving you trouble to stick with h-9 sport birds and crudokote!
#3193
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
ORIGINAL: timothy thompson
tell the guys giving you trouble to stick with h-9 sport birds and crudokote!
tell the guys giving you trouble to stick with h-9 sport birds and crudokote!
Tom
#3194
Senior Member
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
Tom,
I believe that all Men were created equal. Just because I haven't been on this site as long as them doesn't mean they are better than I am. I just didn't know about it is all. I don't get this putting certain builders up on a pedistal thing that is going on. There is only one God and they aren't him. You are taking sides and that was just a post between Pete and myself. Let him speak for himself and that way everyone can remain friends. But by the way who are these special guy's your talking about other than Pete? You seem to think that they are something very special. Tell me what they have done to deserve special treatment anymore than the next builder. If you can tell me that they are better than me then I'll leave this site and go to RCSCALEBUILDERS.COM which I'm already on where everyone is treated equal. Nobody rates you from 1 to 10 over there. This is where I stand and I'm not going to change so tell me now if I'm not wanted or leave me alone when it comes to what I post in response to what I think is wrong information. By the way Timothy, thank you for your expert advice and backup.
Let me know,
Barry
I believe that all Men were created equal. Just because I haven't been on this site as long as them doesn't mean they are better than I am. I just didn't know about it is all. I don't get this putting certain builders up on a pedistal thing that is going on. There is only one God and they aren't him. You are taking sides and that was just a post between Pete and myself. Let him speak for himself and that way everyone can remain friends. But by the way who are these special guy's your talking about other than Pete? You seem to think that they are something very special. Tell me what they have done to deserve special treatment anymore than the next builder. If you can tell me that they are better than me then I'll leave this site and go to RCSCALEBUILDERS.COM which I'm already on where everyone is treated equal. Nobody rates you from 1 to 10 over there. This is where I stand and I'm not going to change so tell me now if I'm not wanted or leave me alone when it comes to what I post in response to what I think is wrong information. By the way Timothy, thank you for your expert advice and backup.
Let me know,
Barry
#3195
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
I believe that fighting on the internet is like running in the special Olympics. Even if you win, you are still special. I was actually just making the point that Oz has some good ideas that are worth hearing. As far as fiberglassing goes, there are about 100 different opinions, so that's a fight that can't be won. I was just amazed at Mr. Thompson's comment. The only 3 people I could figure that he would be talking about would be Oz, Bob T, or me. You'd be hard pressed to find 3 guys that work harder at getting it right, so the crack about H9 and monokote seemed way out of line. Anyhow, I spent my $0.02 on this topic a couple of hours ago, so I'm going back to building my little airplane.
Tom
Tom
#3199
Banned
My Feedback: (1)
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Brisbane, Queensland, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 7,744
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
good luck then mate
if you want to be a know it all wanker then good luck to you, don't waste my time further.
reading below you obviously have no idea of how to do glassing properly so that a lightweight result is achieved. By all means fill it with filler and layers of resin. You will end up with a grossly overweight model that will be a pig.
the best of british to you and your brick!
But then I know nothing of such matters as you have aluded to.
if you want to be a know it all wanker then good luck to you, don't waste my time further.
reading below you obviously have no idea of how to do glassing properly so that a lightweight result is achieved. By all means fill it with filler and layers of resin. You will end up with a grossly overweight model that will be a pig.
the best of british to you and your brick!
But then I know nothing of such matters as you have aluded to.
ORIGINAL: NCIS
Peter_OZ,
Automotive red spot putty is very light and won't add POUNDS to the job. Have you ever tried it or are you just guessing. I have read numerous articles about it. It is a very light way to finish the plane. The weave will be filled except after taking all the excess resin off thy cloth there will be a slightly pourous surface. I'm not talking about filling all the weave way into the cloth with putty but just a very thin layer which will then be sanded smooth to the cloth. It will almost all disappear. I think you are just knocking it because you have never tried it before. I have and know what I'm talking about!!! Have you ever done fiberglass repair on a full scale aircraft, I don't think so? I have. It has to meet high standards to be cleared to fly! You do it your way and we will do it our way.
Thanks but no thanks,
Gibbs
Peter_OZ,
Automotive red spot putty is very light and won't add POUNDS to the job. Have you ever tried it or are you just guessing. I have read numerous articles about it. It is a very light way to finish the plane. The weave will be filled except after taking all the excess resin off thy cloth there will be a slightly pourous surface. I'm not talking about filling all the weave way into the cloth with putty but just a very thin layer which will then be sanded smooth to the cloth. It will almost all disappear. I think you are just knocking it because you have never tried it before. I have and know what I'm talking about!!! Have you ever done fiberglass repair on a full scale aircraft, I don't think so? I have. It has to meet high standards to be cleared to fly! You do it your way and we will do it our way.
Thanks but no thanks,
Gibbs
#3200
Senior Member
RE: GROUP BUILD - Top Flite Giant Scale F4U Corsair
Your the one that think's he know's it all MATE![:@] I don't need or want any help from some Aussie with you attitude an CAPS.
GIBBS
GIBBS