Go Back  RCU Forums > Electric Aircraft Universe > Brushed/Brushless motors, speed controls, gear drives
Reload this Page >

Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?

Notices
Brushed/Brushless motors, speed controls, gear drives Discuss all aspects of brushless motors, brushed motors, speed controls (ESC's), gear drives and propellers in this forum.

Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?

Old 02-28-2013, 08:43 AM
  #1  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



HERE IS ALIST OF KNOWN CURRENT MANUFACTURERS OF BRUSHLESS MOTORS:
-Please feel free to add to this list, if you know of any other manufacturers that have been missed off:

A very major manufacturer of brushless motors is:
SunRay Technology Co., Ltd. Shenzhen: http://sunraytechnology.com
Manufacturer of: HACKER outrunner motors, Extreme-Flight TORQUE brushless motors

-IMPORTANTLY, it now appears certain that SunRay Technology also manufacture the "TURNIGY SK3" range of motors (sold by HobbyKing) -which appear to be identical motorsto HACKER and TORQUE motors, and also to:Z-HYPERION, LIPOLICE, PELIKAN FOXY, GENS ACE motors -and to other brands made by this factory (see below) ...
-It seems that TURNIGY SK3 motors may be essentially identical to matching-sizeHACKER and TORQUE motors, the big difference being that that TURNIGY SK3 motors only cost ~30% that of HACKER and TORQUE motors. TURNIGY SK3 motors may actually be HACKER motors for 1/3 of the price ....

-SunRay Technology also manufacture: "LIPOLICE" motors (Schweighofer, Austria), RCM-PELIKAN "FOXY" brushless motors (sold by: PelikanDaniel, Puffin models), GENS ACE motors, Shulman Aviation "FURY" motors, OK HOBBY INFINITE motors, VIPER VA20 motors, SONIC ELECTRIC SE motors, MEGAPOWER TAURUS motors -all these brands of motor have identical specs and appear to be the same as HACKER and TORQUE motors (-which are themselves clones ofgeneric SunRay motors).
-SunRayalso manufacture HYPERION "Z"-SERIES motors (-the older series of Hyperion motors, before the "ZS" series. "ZS"motors aremanufactured by Scorpion, and Hyperion "ZS"motors are identical to Scorpion)-The older Hyperion "Z" series motors have identical specs to HACKER, TORQUE, LIPOLICE, GENS ACE, OK HOBBY INFINITE, etc etc (see later posts in this thread).
-Puffin Models website actually states: "Pelikan Foxy Brushless Motors .... are produced by the manufacturer of Hacker outrunner motors" - http://www.puffinmodels.com/category.php?dept=281 -The situation is therefore very clear indeed.

-SunRay Technology factory also make: NOVA-LINE motors (sold by PILOTAGE-RC.COM in Eastern Europe), LIPOTECH motors (sold in Italy) -both have same external look to Torque motors;Nova-Line and Lipotechmotors have identical specs to Hacker, Torque, Z-Hyperion motors and all the other brands.
-Sunray also make APACHE motors -some look identical externally toHacker, others look identical toTorque; -they are sold by ANYRC.COM and others in Korea and Far East. - http://www.anyrc.com/product_html/pr...&bc_number=101 In Europe, APACHE motors are sold by SLOWFLYER.CH in Switzerland-http://www.slowflyer.ch Apache motors have identical specs to Hacker, Torque, Z-Hyperion motors and all the other brands.

-Shulman Aviation FURY motors -some look similar to GENS ACE motors, some look similar to Hyperion-Z orSK3 motors; FURY motorshave an identical naming system to HACKER, and have identical specs to HACKER / TORQUE/Z-Hyperion motors etc etc -therefore it is certain that the "FURY" motors come from the same SunRay Technology factory as HACKER, TORQUE, GENS ACE etc -see http://shulmanaviation.com/index.php...30b9b2b0c069b6
-Note Shulman website states: "FURY motors feature Quality NSK {JAPAN} Ball Bearings, Curved neo-magnets, and high efficiency stator design" -an identical statement made widely for HACKER motors. For instance, Aeroshack states for all HACKER motors: "These motors .... feature Oversize bearings, Curved Neo-magnets and High efficiency stator design". - http://www.aeroshack.co.uk/shop/gbu0...kerMotors.html

It isalmost certain(99%)thatSunRay Technology also manufacture the O.S. "OMA" series of brushless motors, and the Futaba FMA50mm diam motors.
Sunray Technology also make: The BMI-Models Spitz range of motors; the Precision Aerobatics THRUST motors;and also the Common-Sense-RC E-series of motors(now largely discontinued -just a few left, they say...). They also make the BOOST range of motors (available from Robotbirds in UK -they look really nice motors ... -very similar appearance to the Z-Hyperion motors). All these ranges of motors have identical specs to Hacker, Torque, Z-Hyperionand all the other brands (see later posts in this thread).

-SunRay Technology also make many ESC's -they manufacture:Hacker,Hyperion Titan and Airboss ESC's.They also makeCommon-Sense-RC;Sonic Electric; Gens Ace,OK Hobby Infinite;BMI-Models Spitz;Shulman Aviation;Apache;and also Turnigy Trust ESC's.They also make the range ofTURNIGY DLUXdata logging ESC's (sold by HobbyKing-identical to BMI Spitz data log ESC's)
See: http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/fb.asp?m=11452486 -post #43 onwards

The fact that the Sunray Technology factory makesboth ESC's and brushless motorshas been confirmed by ExtremeFlight themselves,
see:
http://www.extremeflightrc.com/html/news.html -in"Spring/Summer 2011 news" pictures -where Chris Hinson comments: "... Nelson (Fong) manufactures our Torque motors and Airboss ESCs and traveled all the way from China to attend SEFF this year ..." -Note that: Nelson Fong is the owner of the SunRay Technology factory, in Shenzhen, China.


XYH, EMP, Electric
Model Power http://en.xingyaohua.com/html/default.html -Also sold as: Turnigy "standard" -these areXYH "C-type" motors;Turnigy "AerodriveXp SK" -these were XYH "N-type" motors; Also sold as: Turnigy "L"-type "Air" motors, HobbyKing NTM Prop-drive motors, Purple Power "4-max" -ALL the 4Max "Purple Power" motors are made by XYH .., XYHmotors also sold as: Overlander "Tornado Thumper", some older DualSky, Ray, Pelikan "Ray", Hextronic, HXT, Exceed RC, Aeolian, Gemini, Aeronuts, Firepower, Twister, B*********, BRC "Wasp" motors-and many other names; Also sold on eBay as "Red EMP", "Mystery", "Blue Silver" "Power" and many other names...: It isverypossible that TACON motors (sold by Hobbypartz.com) are made by XYH(-theyhave similar specsto E-Flite motors, and use a similar "IC equivalent"naming system to E-Flite).However,Tacon motors are identical to Exceed-RC "Monster Power" motors, which are almost certainly XYH-EMP motors. A few retailers e.g. Giant Shark in the UK, actually sell these motors as "XYH"motors -this is unusual. Some retailers sell these motors as "EMP"motors.


Zhuhai Huamai Electronics and Model, also called: Chinahimark, Himark, Himax, Himark Electronic & Model Co: http://www.chinahimark.com/ - (see http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=248261 -the chinahimark.com website stopped working in late 2012 ... Perhaps as an OEM manufacturer, they no longer wished to show their motors publicly ?)
They are: Manufacturer of all E-FLITE motors.

Chinahimark also manufacture all the "HIMAX" motors, sold by MAXX PRODUCTS - http://www.maxxprod.com -and distributed in Europe as: e.g. "Multilpex Himax", "JPEnerg" and "TopModel XPower" motors (and probably others brands also ...). Some of the Chinahimarkmotors are also labelled as "HIMARK" motors -especially in Australia / New Zealand / Far East. The Multilpex Himax", "JPEnerg" and "TopModel XPower" motors all appear largely identical in both appearance and in specification to to each other, ansd also to E-Flite motors.
The Chinahimark factory almost certainly also make the Turnigy "EasyMatch" G-Series motors -which appear identical in naming,in all specs and in appearance to E-Flite motors.
The Chinahimark factory alsomake the larger (35mm diam) LogicRC Fusion motors and also some Tahmazo motors, as these appear identical in specs and in appearance to XPower, E-Flite and Himax motors. The 35mm diam LogicRC Fusion are also the same as Robbe Roxy 35mm motors.
E-FLITE motors are similar (but NOT identical) in specsto TACON motors (sold by Hobbypartz.com). Tacon have a different external appearance. Tacon motors may possibly be made by Chinahimark factory, however it is much morelikelythey are made by the XYH-EMP factory.


Suppo Model: ( -Also sold as: Turnigy "H" motors, Mystery, HiModel, Giant Cod / Giant Shark "SP", Giant Shark "Strong Power" motors, Grayson, BP Hobbies, Helimate, Dynamo, B********* -and many other brand names ... ): http://www.suppomodel.com/ Sold as "Suppo" motors (i.e. original brand name)by Altitude Hobbies in USA, and some other retailers (i.e. BPHobbies).

EMAX, YinYan Model, LoongMax ( -Also sold as: Turnigy "Typhoon" heli motors, Giant Shark "E-Power" ): http://www.yinyanmodel.com/
KEDA: http://www.kedamodel.com/ -often shown as "KD" motors -are basically poor low-quality copies of Hacker motors
Dong Yang Servo Power Model Co.,Ltd: -Manufacturer of the DYS motors, which are also "Turnigy XP" motors: http://www.dys.hk/

Aoyuxiang, Aoxan, Aoxing: http://aoxan.en.alibaba.com/ http://aoxan.en.gongchang.com/
Once Top Motor Manufacture Co., Ltd: www.wanzhida.cn-have been suggested to manufature some Horizon Hobby (including E-Flite) motors

Pulso Motors
(-Also sold as: Innov8tive "Cobra" motors -with small changes- in USA): http://www.pulsosystem.com/
Motrolfly: http://www.motrolfly.com/ -part of a larger company, called Shenzhen DBY Technology Co. Ltd: http://www.dby-tech.com/products/
Tiger Motor, T-Motor: http://www.rctigermotor.com/ - -older versions of T-motor are same as the "Exceed-RC Legend" motors sold by Hobbypartz
Topband Motor, Shenzhen Topband CO., LTD - http://www.topbandmotor.com/en/chi/a...=161&comid=113 -Manufacturer of Exceed-RC "Optima" motors, and also of E-Flite EDF and Turnigy EDF motors

Shenzhen Feisuda Motor factory - www.fsd-motor.com -is manufacturer of Leopard motors http://www.leopardhobby.com/enindex.asp -these are the same as Power-HD motors - http://www.chd.hk/Product_List.aspx?cid=19&page=1 -and are also the same as Overlander "Tornado Thumber V2 MK2" motors.
-Shenzhen Feisuda Motors "fsd-motor" -are also often sold as "FC" motors and as "FSD" motors -Many of them can be seen on the HiModel website as "Type FC" motors and they can also can be seen on eBay as "FSD" motors. The motors sold by MileHighRC with black can/gold end housings are made by FSD.

Dualsky motors:
http://www.dualsky.com/product.asp?s...id=128&lid=146 -They appear to manufacture in own factory

SJ-Propo (Their chinese factory is: Aisijie Technology, in Shenzhen): http://sjproporc.com/ -SJ-Propo is a South Korean company.
( -Aisijie Technology is the previous chinese manufacturer of HACKER outrunner motors, before SunRay Technology took over).
(Just possible that O.S and Futabaoutrunner motors made by SJ-PROPO-but unlikely;SJ-PROPO manufactures the O.S and Futaba range of ESC's, and may also makeother O.S. and Futabadevices - http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/m_11215832/tm.htm )
See http://www.sjproporc.com/product-brushless.htm for current SJ Propo brushless motors.-These are the same motors as 28mm diam LogicRC Fusion and Tahmazo brushless motors (not surprising, since there is a close relation between SJ Propo, Fusion, LogicRC and Tahmazo .. ).They are also thesame as Robbe Roxxy 28mmdiam motors.

Sunny Sky Model Co., Ltd, Zhongshan City: http://www.rcsunnysky.com
Sunrise Motor, Changzhou Sunrise Electric Motor Company: http://www.china-bldcmotor.com/
HobbyKing: http://www.hobbyking.com; For instance, they claim to manufacture the "NTM" series of motors themselves, in their own chinese factory; But actually, NTMmotors are manufactured by the XYH factory ...

Scorpion: Well-known manufacturer of high quality brushless motors; Also sold as the Hyperion "ZS" series of motors. http://www.scorpionsystem.com
ZhuHai GS Model Accessories Mfg: http://www.gsmodels.com/en/introduce.html -Manufacturer of AXI "Silver series" motors; They also manufacture the Turnigy "CA" brushless motors sold by HobbyKing -i.e. CA 80-80 (50cc equiv.) and CA 120-70 (100cc equiv.)

Shenzhen Saite Motor Co., Ltd: http://www.saite-motor.com/about-us
Oversky motors (motors mostly for small planes and helis): http://www.overskyrc.com/index.php?m...=index&cPath=1

ARC motor: -manufacturer website unknown
HET motor, High-End Technology RC: http://www.highendrc.com/

Neu Motors: http://www.neumotors.com/Site/Welcome.html

Model Motors, AXI: http://www.modelmotors.cz/
Hacker (inrunner motors still made in Germany, outrunners made in above SunRay Technology Chinese factory):http://www.hacker-motor-shop.com/e-v...og&t=3&c=3&p=3
PJS Motors (very high quality, little used in 2012 ...): http://www.pjs.cz/index.php?cPath=1
Mega Motors: http://www.megamotor.cz/v3/script/de...ge_id=lang_eng
Kontronik: http://www.kontronik.com/index.php?o...emid=6&lang=en
MVVS: http://www.mvvs.cz/elektromotory_e.html
Plettenberg: http://www.plettenberg-motoren.com/UK/index.htm
Torcman: http://www.torcman.de/index_e.htm
Lehner: http://www.lehner-motoren.com/
Flyware: http://www.flyware.de/

Align: http://www.align.com.tw/shop/index.p...67&language=en
Actro: http://www.actro.de/de/allg/index.html

Cyclon: Were developed by Fabrice Noro, in France: website used to be: http://www.electronicmodel.com/ - http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=15862
-These motors used to be sold by Horizon Hobby - http://www.horizonhobby.com/products...-motor-CYLOR30
-They appear to be still sold by Singapore Hobby Supplies - http://www.singahobby.com/?q=node/16740
-Manufacturer of these motors is not known
Also see: http://www.befa.ef-uk.net/ef-uk/issues/EF-UK-79.pdf pages 16, 17, 18


OTHER CHINESE FACTORIES MAKING BRUSHLESS MOTORS:
Chongqing Maitian Mechanical & Electrical Co., Ltd: www.maitian.com.cn/BLMOTOR.htm
China Topwin Industry Co.,Ltd: http://www.chinatopwin.com/
Shenzhen Power Motor Industrial Co: http://www.power-motor.com/
Dernfu Electronic (Dongguan) Co., Ltd: http://dernfu.en.alibaba.com/product...ess_Motor.html

DrMotor is offline  
Old 02-28-2013, 10:07 AM
  #2  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



COMPARISON OF THE DIFFERENT BRAND MOTORS MADE AT THE SUNRAY TECHNOLOGY FACTORY

INDOOR-SIZE MOTORS (21mm and 28mm diameter)
(listed in order of weight, ascending Kv, and number of turns-descending), (LP =LiPolice)
(For Turnigy SK3: Stated "Can length" is 1 to 3mm longer than stator length; and can be used to identify stator length of each motor;
"2118" -size motor has 1705 stator; "2122" motor has 1709 stator; "2822" motor has 2205 stator )

15g, 16g
(these motors have a 1705 stator -i.e. stator is 17mm diam, 5mm length)

SunRay 1705-1825Kv 14T, 16g=LP-1705/14T-1825KV=Infinite A1705-1800, 14T=HYPERION Z1705-14T 1800 KV=Foxy C1705/14 1825 Kv



Gens ACE Mars BL2118-2050KV, 16T, 16.5g(-with Kv 2050, would expect less turns than 16T ?)



SunRay 1705-2275Kv 11T=Turnigy SK3 2118-2250kv, 11T=LP-1705/11T-2275KV =Infinite A1705-2250, 11T=HYPERION Z1705-11T 2250 KV

Hacker 15g, A10-15 S, Kv 2320, ?15T, 12pole, D21 L21=FURY SA-10-15S / 2320Kv, ?15T, 15g=~Turnigy SK3 2118-2250kv, 11T=~LP-1705/11T-2275KV =~Infinite A1705-2250, 11T=~HYPERION Z1705-11T 2250 KV



Turnigy SK3 2118-2750kv, 9T



Hacker 15g, A10-12 S, Kv 2900, ?12T, 12pole, D21 L21=Fury-SA-10 ?12S / 2900Kv, 12T



Turnigy SK3 2118-3100kv, 8T

(Note: These 15g, 16g motors are listed in order of Kv. However, in this small section, quoted number of turns does not completely correlate with Kv -as it does for ALL other motors listed, up to 60-size motors. -I suspect theHacker A10-15 Sis actually an 11T motor, and that the Hacker A10-12 S is probably more like an 8T or 9T motor ...)




20g
(these motors have 1709 stator)

Hacker 20g, A10-13L, Kv 1200, 13T, 12pole, D21 L25



Hacker 20g, A10-9L, Kv 1700, 9T, 12pole, D21 L25=FURY SA-10-9L-1700 Kv, 9T =~SunRay 1709-1580Kv 9T=~Turnigy SK3 2122-1570kv=~LP-1709/9T-1580KV=~Infinite A1709-1500, 9T=HYPERION Z1709-9T 1500 KV=Foxy C1709/09 1580 Kv=APACHE APM10-9T, Kv1700=Gens ACE Mars BL2122-1580KV, 9T

(NOTE:Hacker A10-9 Lhas a quoted Kv 1700; However, other identical motors with the same 1709 stator and 9T, quote Kv 1500 (Hyperion); Kv 1580 (LiPolice LP); Kv 1580 (Gens Ace)
DriveCalc shows that for these small motors, the measured Kv may actually be about 100 different from the Kv quoted by the brander / retailer.
For instance, DriveCalc shows that the LiPolice Z1705-11T 2250 KV has a measured Kv of 2461 rpm /V -200 more than the quoted manuf Kv;
It seems highly likely that the actual Kv for the Hacker / Fury A10-9 L is more like 1600;and also that Kv of the Infinite / Hyperion1709 9T will be more like 1600 -this will make the Kv's of all these motors very similar )

Turnigy SK3 - 2122-1800kv, 8T



Hacker 20g, A10-7L, Kv 2200, 7T, 12pole, D21 L25=SunRay 1709-2180Kv 7T=Turnigy SK3 2122-2100kv, 7T=LP-1709/7T-2180KV=Infinite A1709-2100, 7T=HYPERION Z1709-7T 2100 KV=Nova-Line DT1709/07-2200, 7T =Fury-SA-10-7L-2200Kv, 7T




29g
(these motors have 2205 stator)

Hacker 29g, A20-50 S EVO, Kv 1088, 50T, D28, L22=Turnigy SK3 2822-1090kv, 50T=Nova Line DT2205, 50T -1090

Hyperion HP-Z2205-46T, Kv 1200



Turnigy SK3 2822-1275kv, 40T



Nova Line DT2205/38-1340, 38T =Hyperion HP-Z2205-38T, Kv 1370



SunRay 2205-1600Kv 36T=LP-2205/36T-1600KV=Foxy C2205/36 1600 Kv =Infinite A2205-1560, 36T

Hacker 29g, A20-34S EVO, Kv 1500, 34T, D28, L22=Torque 34T/1520, 29g, Kv 1520 34T=FURY SA-20-34S/1500Kv, 34T =APACHE APS20-34T 1520 Kv =Viper VA20-34S 1500 Kv=Lipotech ST1525 1525 Kv =Gens ACE Mars BL2718-1600KV, 34T



SunRay 2205-1800Kv 32T=LP-2205/32T-1800KV=Infinite A2205-1740, 32T



Turnigy SK3 2822-1740kv, 30T


Source of these data:
SUNRAY TECH data from: Their own information, spreadsheets provided by the SunRay factory themselves
HACKER motor data from: http://www.hacker-motor-shop.com/e-v...og&t=3&c=3&p=3
Extreme Flight TORQUE data from: http://www.extremeflightrc.com/html/torque.html
TURNIGY SK3 data from: http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/s...&v=&sortlist=W
LIPOLICE (LP) data from: http://www.der-schweighofer.at/en/gr...shless_engines
OK Hobby INFINITE motor data from: http://www.okhobby.com/category.php?id_category=169
HYPERION Z SERIES data from: http://www.aircraft-world.com/shopdi...que+outrunners and http://www.b-p-p.com/home.php?cat=30...ction=0&page=3
RCM-PELIKAN "FOXY" motor data from: http://air.pelikandaniel.com/?sec=ca...en&category=21 ; http://www.puffinmodels.com/category.php?dept=281
APACHE motor data from: http://www.anyrc.com/product_html/pr...&bc_number=101 and http://www.slowflyer.ch/elektro-antr...ache/index.php
PILOTAGE NOVA LINE motor data from: http://www.pilotage-rc.com.ua/catalogue/85_/85_20/ ; http://www.pilotage-rc.ru/support/ma...ine_manual.pdf
LIPOTECH motor data from: http://www.lipotech.net/store/index....index&cPath=19
VIPER VA motor data from: http://foamyfactory.com/viper-motors.htm
GENS ACE motor data from: http://www.gensace.com/epages/genspo...irplane_Series
MEGAPOWER TAURUS motor data from: http://www.megapower-rc.com/index.php?cPath=12_35_131
O.S. motor data from: http://www.osengines.com/motors/index.html
FUTABA motor data from: http://www.rc.futaba.co.jp/motor/
SHULMAN AVIATION "FURY" motor data from: http://shulmanaviation.com/index.php?cPath=176
SONIC ELECTRIC motor data from: http://www.sonicelectric.com/Merchan...tegory_Code=EM
COMMON-SENSE-RC motor data from: http://www.commonsenserc.com/page.php?page=ezmatch.html
PRECISION AEROBATICS THRUST motor data from: http://www.precisionaerobatics.com/t...ors/index.html
BMI-Models Spitz motor data from: http://www.bmi-models.com/index.php?...s_motor/4/1401

DrMotor is offline  
Old 02-28-2013, 10:14 AM
  #3  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



PARK FLYER -SIZE MOTORS (28mm diameter)
(listed in order of weight, ascending Kv, and number of turns -descending), (LP =LiPolice)
(For Turnigy SK3: Stated "Can length" is 3 to 4mm longer than stator length, and can be used to identify stator length of each motor;
"2826" -size motor has 2209 stator; "2830" motor has 2213 stator; "2836" motor has 2219 stator )



42g
(these motors have 2209 stator)

Hyperion Z2209 32T, 910-Kv, 42g, D28 L29=SONIC ELECTRIC SE-2809-910, 32T, 43g, D28 L29=Pilotage Nova Line DT2209/32-910, 32T



Hacker 42g, A20-30 M EVO, Kv 980, 30T, D28 L30=SunRay 2209-980Kv 30T, D28 L28=Torque 30T/980=Turnigy SK3 2826-980kv, 30T=LP-2209/30T-980KV=Infinite A2209-950, 30T=Foxy C2209/30 980 Kv =APACHE APM20-30T, 980 Kv=Gens ACE Mars BL2722-980KV, 30T=PA Thrust A10 Brushless motor, 41g, Kv 975, D28 L31



Apache A20-28M, 42g, Kv 1050, 28T =Viper VA20-28M 1050 Kv=Pilotage Nova Line DT2209/28-1048



Hacker 42g, A20-26 M EVO, Kv 1130, 26T, D28 L30=SunRay 2209-1180Kv 26T=Torque 26T/1135=Turnigy SK3 2826-1130kv, 26T=HYPERION Z2209-26T 1120 KV=LP-2209/24T-1180KV=Infinite A2209-1160, 24T=Foxy C2209/26 1180 Kv=BMI TURBO 08, 41g, Kv 1150, D28



Turnigy SK3 2826-1240kv, 22T=APACHE APM20-22T 1400 Kv


55g
(these motors have2213 stator)

SunRay 2213-880Kv, 24T, D28 L32=LP-2213/24T-880KV=Infinite A2213-862, 24T=HYPERION Z2213-24T 850 KV=Foxy C2213/24 880 Kv



Hacker 55g, A20-22 L-EVO, Kv 925, 22T, D28 L33=SunRay 2213-980Kv 22T=Torque 22T/930=Turnigy SK3 2830-920kv, 22T=LP-2213/22T-980KV=Infinite A2213-970, 22T=APACHE APL20-22T 938 Kv=Pilotage Nova Line DT2213/22-924=Lipotech GT 925 925 Kv, 57g, 22T=Gens ACE Mars BL2726-960KV, 22T



Hacker 55g, A20-20 L-EVO, Kv 1022, 20T, D28 L33=SunRay 2213-1080Kv 20T=Torque 20T/1030=Turnigy SK3 2830-1020kv, 20T=LP-2213/20T-1080KV=Infinite A2213-1070, 20T=HYPERION Z2213-20T 1025 KV=Foxy C2213/20 1080 Kv =APACHE APL20-20T 1020Kv=Viper VA20-20L 1020 Kv=Pilotage Nova Line DT2213/20-1022=Lipotech GT 1025 1025 Kv, 57g, 20T=FURY SA-20-20L/1022Kv=SONIC ELECTRIC SE-2813-1020, 57g, 20T, D28 L33=BMI TURBO 10, 55g, Kv 1025, D28

SunRay 2213-1200Kv 18T=Turnigy SK3 2830-1130kv, 18T=LP-2213 /18T-1200KV=Infinite A2213-1190, 18T=APACHE APL20-18T 1200 Kv=~Common-Sense-RC E5-L-10, 56g, Kv 1300



HYPERION Z2213-16T 1470 KV



78g
(these motors have 2219 stator)

Hacker 78g, A20-12 XL EVO, Kv 1039, 12T, 14 pole, D28 L 40=Turnigy SK3 2836-1040kv, 12T, 14 pole=APACHE APXL20-12T 1039 Kv



Hacker 78g, A20-8 XL EVO, Kv 1500, 8T, 14 pole, D28 L40=Turnigy SK3 2836-1500kv, 8T, 14 pole=APACHE APXL20-8T 1500 Kv



Hacker 78g, A20-6 XL 10-Pole EVO, Kv 2500, 6T, 10pole, D28 L40=Turnigy SK3 2836-2500kv, 6T=APACHE APXL20-6T 2500 Kv=Lipotech GT2600 2600 Kv



Hacker 78g, A20-6 XL 8-Pole EVO, Kv 3500, 6T, 8pole, D28 L40

DrMotor is offline  
Old 02-28-2013, 12:21 PM
  #4  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



30-SIZE MOTORS (37mm, 38mm diameter)
(listed in order of weight, ascending Kv and number of turns -descending), (LP =LiPolice)
(For Turnigy SK3: Stated "Can length" is 3 to 4mm longer than stator length, and can be used to identify stator length of each motor;
"3530" -size motor has 3007 stator; "3536" motor has 3014 stator; "3542" motor has 3019/3020 stator; "3548" motor has 3025 stator)



72g
(these motors have 3007 stator -i.e stator is: 30mm diam, 7mm length)

Torque 2830T/1095, 70g, Kv 1095, 30T=APACHE APS30-30T 1070 kV=Lipotech GTA 8/30 1070 Kv



Hacker 72g, A30-28-S-V2, Kv 1140, 28T, 14pole, D37 L32=SunRay 3007-1100Kv 28T=Turnigy SK3 3530-1150kv, 28T=LP-3007/28T-1100KV=Infinite A3007-1100, 28T=Gens ACE Mars BL3732-1100KV, 28T



SunRay 3007-1240Kv 26T=LP-3007/26T-1240KV=Infinite A3007-1240, 26T=HYPERION Z3007-26T 1240 KV=Foxy C3007/26 1240 Kv=Nova Line DT3007/26-1240=Lipotech GTA 8/26 1250 Kv



Turnigy 3530-1340kv, 24T



Hacker 72g, A30-22-S-V2, Kv 1440, 22T, 14pole, D37 L32=Turnigy SK3 3530-1460kv, 22T =FURY SA-30-22S/1440Kv



SunRay 3007-1580Kv 20T=LP-3007/20T-1580KV=Infinite A3007-1580, 20T



104g

OS OMA-3810 Kv 1050, 105g, D38 L33 (-O.S. state this motor has: 3010 stator )

(the motors below have 3014 stator)



Torque 2818T/900 104g; Kv 900=APACHE APM30-18T 900 Kv=Nova Line DT3013/18 -900



Hacker 104g, A30-16-M-V2, Kv 1060, 16T, 14pole, D37 L38=SunRay 3014-972Kv 16T=Turnigy SK3 3536-1050kv, 16T=LP-3014/16T-972KV= Infinite A3014-972, 16T=HYPERION Z3013-16T 985 KV=Foxy C3014/16 970 Kv=APACHE APM30-16T 1040 Kv=Lipotech GTA 14-16 970 Kv=FURY SA-30-16M/1060Kv=? O.S. OMA-3815, Kv 1000, 130g, D38, L38, 16T, 14 pole

SunRay 3014-1132Kv 14T=Turnigy SK3 3536-1200kv, 14T=LP-3014/14T-1132KV= Infinite A3014-1132, 14T=HYPERION Z3013-14T 1085 KV=Foxy C3014/14 1132Kv=Lipotech GTA 14-14 1090 Kv



Hacker 104g, A30-12-M-V2, Kv 1370, 12T, 14pole, D37 L38=Turnigy SK3 3536-1400kv, 12T



143g
(these motors have 3020 stator)

Hacker 143g, A30-14-L-V2, Kv 800, 14T, 14pole, D37 L43, =Turnigy SK3 3542-800Kv 14T=Torque 2814T/820 143g; Kv 820=APACHE APL30-14T 815 Kv=Nova Line DT3019/14-800=Gens ACE Mars BL3744-800KV, 14T



Hacker 143g, A30-12-L-V2, Kv 1000, 12T, 14pole, D37 L43, =SunRay 3020-970Kv 12T=Turnigy SK3 3542-1000kv, 12T=LP-3020/12T-970KV=Infinite A3020-970, 12T=HYPERION Z3019-12T 900 KV=Foxy C3020/12 970Kv=Nova Line DT3019/12 970 Kv=Lipotech GTA 20-12 900 Kv = ? O.S. OMA-3820 Kv 960, 160g, D38 L44, 12T, 14 pole (-will have 3020 stator)



Hacker 143g, A30-10-L-V2, Kv 1185, 10T, 14pole, D37 L43, =SunRay 3020-1135 10T=Turnigy SK3 3542-1185kv, 10T=LP-3020/10T-1135KV=Infinite A3020-1135, 10T=HYPERION Z3019-10T 1070 KV=Foxy C3020/10 1135 Kv=Lipotech GTA 20-10 1080 Kv

Turnigy SK3 3542-1250kv, 8T




177g
(these motors have 3025 stator)

Torque 2814T / 605, 177g, 605 Kv, 14T=APACHE APXL30-14T 610 Kv



Hacker 177g, A30-12 XL V2, Kv 700, 12T, 14pole, D37 L49, =SunRay 3025-770Kv 12T =Torque 2812T/720, Kv 720=Turnigy SK3 3548-700kv, 12T=LP-3025/12T-770KV=Infinite A3025-770, 12T=HYPERION Z3025-12T 685 KV=Foxy C3025/12 770 Kv=APACHE APXL30-12T 750 Kv=Nova Line DT3025/12-750=Gens ACE Mars BL3749-770KV, 12T = ? O.S. OMA-3825 Kv 750, 190g, ?12T, D38 L48, 14 pole(-will have 3025 stator)




Hacker 177g, A30-10 XL V2, Kv 900, 10T, 14pole, D37 L49, =SunRay 3025-890Kv 10T=Turnigy SK3 3548-840kv, 10T=LP-3025/10T-890KV=Infinite A3025-890, 10T=HYPERION Z-3025 10T 815 KV=Foxy C3025/10 890 Kv=APACHE APXL30-10T 860 Kv=Nova Line DT3025/10-900=Lipotech GTA 26-10



Hacker 177g, A30-8 XL V2, Kv 1100, 8T, 14pole, D37 L49, =SunRay 3025-1090Kv 8T=Turnigy SK3 3548-1050kv, 8T=LP-3025/8T-1090KV=Infinite A3025-1090, 8T=HYPERION Z3025-8T 985 KV=APACHE APXL30-8T 1100 Kv

DrMotor is offline  
Old 02-28-2013, 06:27 PM
  #5  
rosnik
Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: 1000MIGLIA CITY, ITALY
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?

UAHUUUUUUUU!!!!!!!!
really interesting, mate!
rosnik is offline  
Old 03-01-2013, 08:03 AM
  #6  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



50-SIZE MOTORS (49mm, 50mm diameter)
(listed in order of weight, ascending Kv, and number of turns -descending), (LP =LiPolice)
(For Turnigy SK3 motors: Stated "Can length" is 3 to 5mm longer than stator length, and can be used to identify stator length of each motor;
All Turnigy SK3 "50"-series motors have diam of 50mm.
SK3 "5045" -size motor has 4020 stator; "5055" motor has 4030 stator; "5065" motor has ~4040 stator (-SK3 5065 motor has large front bearing / fan assembly behind front housing -stator appears to start ~15mm behind front of can )
(Turnigy SK3 50-size motors: Quoted length includes ~4mm collet at back of motor; Actual length of main motor body is ~4mm shorter )

234g
O.S. OMA-5010 Kv 810, 234g, , D50 L43, 14 pole, number turns unknown (-has 4010 stator)


289g
(these motors have 4020 stator)
APACHE APS41-20T 390 Kv



Turnigy SK3 5045-450kv; 280g; 18T, D 50 L 49,14 pole, 12 stator arms =BMI SPITZ 60, (325g), Kv 460, D50 (the "Spitz 60" appears more similar to this Turnigy, than to Hacker A50-14 S motor)



Turnigy SK3 5045-500kv; 280g; 16T=HYPERION Z4020 16T 504 KV, D50 L51 = ? O.S.-OMA-5020 Kv 490, 350g, D50 L53, 14 pole -has 4020 stator)


Hacker 289g, A50-14 XS V2, Kv 564, 14T, 14pole, D49 L47=Sunray 4020-550Kv 14T, D50 L42=Torque 4014T/570 Kv 570, D50 L47=LP-4020 /14T-550KV=HYPERION Z4020 14T 574 KV=Infinite A4020-540, 14T=Foxy C4020/14 550 Kv=APACHE APS41-14T 570 Kv =Lipotech GTA4510 -14 575 Kv, 14T=Gens ACE Mars BL4841-550KV, 14T=BOOST 50 295g, Kv 600, D50 L45



Turnigy SK3 5045-660kv; 280g; 12T, D50 L49=HYPERION Z4020 12T 660 KV, D49 L43



Sunray 4020-755Kv 10T=LP-4020 /10T-755KV=Infinite A4020-770, 10T=HYPERION Z4020 10T 748 KV=Foxy C4020/10 755 Kv=LipoTech GTA4510-10, 750 Kv, 10T



HYPERION Z4020 8T 915KV





345g
(these motors have 4025 stator)

SunRay 4025-325Kv 18T, 335g, D 50 L 47=LP-4025 /18T-325KV=Infinite A4025-320, 18T=Foxy C4025/18 325 Kv



Hacker 345g, A50-16 S V2, Kv 378, 16T, 14pole, D49 L52=SunRay 4025-385Kv 16T, D50 L47=LP-4025 /16T-385KV=Infinite A4025-370, 16T=HYPERION Z4025 16T 368 KV, D50 L51=Foxy C4025/16 385 Kv=Pilotage Nova Line DT4123/16 Kv378=APACHE APL41-16T 320 Kv=LipoTech GTA4520 -16 370 Kv, 16T= ? O.S. OMA-5025 Kv 375, (405g), D 50 L 58, 14 pole(-has 4025 stator)



Hacker 345g, A50-14 S V2, Kv 424, 14T, 14pole, D49 L52=APACHE APL41-14T 380 Kv=Pilotage Nova Line DT4123/14 Kv 425=BMI SPITZ 60, 325g, Kv 460, D49



Hacker 345g, A50-12 S V2, Kv 492, 12T, 14pole, D49 L52=SunRay 4025-510Kv 12T=LP-4025 /12T-510KV=Infinite A4025-505, 12T=HYPERION Z4025 12T 486 KV=APACHE APL41-12T 420 Kv=Pilotage Nova Line DT4123/12 -473Kv=BOOST 60 345g, Kv 490, D50 L50



Pilotage Nova Line DT4123/10 -590Kv=HYPERION Z4025 10T 570 KV=APACHE APL41-10T Kv550=Lipotech GTA4520 -10 570 Kv, 10T= BMI SPITZ 46, 325g, Kv 580, D49


369g
(these motors have 4030 stator)

Turnigy SK3 5055-280kv, 18T, 369g, D 50, L 59(-Can length is 34mm, stator is ~4mm shorter -showing 4030 stator)



Turnigy SK3 5055-320kv, 16T=Gens ACE Mars BL4850-340KV, 16T, 370g (-Gens Ace specs quote 4030 stator)



Futaba FMA-5055,330g,KV410, D50 L55 (number turns prob. 12T ?) =~Turnigy SK3 5055-430kv, (370g), 12T, D50 L59

Futaba FMA-5055, 330g, KV525




430g
(these motors have 4035 stator)



Hacker 430g, A50-16 L V2, Kv 272, 16T, 14pole, D49 L62=Apache APM 5035-16T 270 Kv, (485g)=BMI SPITZ 90, 410g, Kv 270, D49



Hacker 430g, A50-14 L V2, Kv 300, 14T, 14pole, D49 L62=SunRay 4035-310Kv 14T, 445g, D50 L56= LP-4035 /14T-310KV=Infinite A4035-300, 14T=HYPERION Z4035 14T 299 KV=Foxy C4035/14 310 Kv = Apache APM 5035-14T Kv 320=Pilotage Nova Line DT4133/14-354=Lipotech GTA4530 -14 300 Kv, 14T=?BOOST 90 455g, Kv 300, D50 L60 =Futaba FMA-5065, 441g, KV300, D50 L64 (number turns unknown -prob. 14T)


Hacker 430g, A50-12 L V2, Kv 345, 12T, 14pole, D49 L62=SunRay 4035-375Kv 12T=LP-4035 /12T-375KV =Infinite A4035-360, 12T=HYPERION Z4035 12T 343 KV=Foxy C4035/12 375 Kv=BMI SPITZ 80, 410g, Kv 340=BOOST 80 (395g), Kv 340, D50 L55



HYPERION Z4035 10T 405 KV =APACHE APM5035-10T 440 Kv=Pilotage Nova Line DT4133/10-443=Lipotech GTA4530 -10 410 Kv, 10T



530g
(SK3 5065 motor hascan length 57mm; due to front bearing / fan assembly, stator starts ~15mm behind front of can -indicating 4040 stator)

Turnigy SK3 5065-236kv;530g; 10T,D50 L82

Turnigy SK3 5065-275kv;530g; 8T



Futaba FMA-5065, KV300, (no. turns unknown)



Turnigy SK3 5065-320kv;530g; 6T;



550g
(these motors have 4045 stator)

HYPERION Z4045 14T 236 KV, 553g, D48 L70 =Lipotech GTA4540 -14, 550g, 240Kv, 14T, D48 L76= ~Turnigy SK3 5065-236kv



HYPERION Z4045 12T 275 KV= ~ Turnigy SK3 5065-275kv;



HYPERION Z4045 10T 320 KV=Lipotech GTA4540 -10, 550g, 320 Kv, 10T= ~ Turnigy SK3 5065-320kv

DrMotor is offline  
Old 03-01-2013, 07:51 PM
  #7  
rosnik
Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: 1000MIGLIA CITY, ITALY
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?

Do you know the paragon of:
Turnigy SK3 4240 740kv ?

TNX
rosnik is offline  
Old 03-02-2013, 12:52 AM
  #8  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



Here is the data for 40 size motors:
It seems that the: Turnigy SK3 4240-740kv, 10T isthe same motor as the: Hacker A40-10S V2 14-Pole, -which also has 10T and an almost identical Kv of 750.


40-SIZE MOTORS (42 mm diameter)
(listed in order of weight, ascending Kv, and number of turns -descending), (LP =LiPolice)
(For Turnigy SK3: Stated "Can length" is 3 to 4mm longer than stator length, and can be used to identify stator length of each motor;
"4240" -size motor has 3520 stator; "4250" motor has 3530 stator )
(Turnigy SK3 40-size motors: Quoted length includes ~6 to 7 mm collet at back of motor; Actual length of the main motor body is ~6mm shorter than this )



182g
Hacker 182g, A40-16S V2 8-Pole, Kv 1000, 16T, 8pole, D42 L42



Hacker 182g, A40-12S V2 8-Pole, Kv 1350, 12T, 8pole, D42 L42




208g
(these motors have 3520 stator)



Hacker 208g, A40-14S V2 14-Pole, Kv 530, 14T, 14pole, D42 L42=Turnigy SK3 4240-530kv, 14T,D42 L50 (motor body has L43 )



Hacker 208g, A40-12S V2 14-Pole, Kv 610, 12T, 14pole, D42 L42=Turnigy SK3 4240-620kv, 12T



Hacker 208g, A40-10S V2 14-Pole, Kv 750, 10T, 14pole, D42 L42=Turnigy SK3 4240-740kv, 10T




246g
Hacker 246g, A40-10L V2 8-Pole, Kv 1100, 10T, 8pole, D42 L42



Hacker 246g, A40-8L V2 8-Pole, Kv 1300, 8T, 8pole, D42 L42




275g
(these motors have 3530 stator)



Hacker 275g, A40-14L V2 14-Pole, Kv 355, 14T, 14pole, D42 L52=Turnigy SK3 4250-350kv, 14T, D42 L58 (motor body has L52 )



Hacker 275g, A40-12L V2 14-Pole, Kv 410, 12T, 14pole, D42 L52=Turnigy SK3 4250-412kv, 12T



Hacker 275g, A40-10L V2 14-Pole, Kv 500, 10T, 14pole, D42 L52=Turnigy SK3 4250-500kv, 10T=Torque 4016T/500 500 Kv, D 41 L 50



Torque 4014T/570 280g, Kv 570, 14T, D 41 L 50=FURY SA-40-14S, 270g, 570Kv, 14T, D 41 L 50



Hacker 275g, A40-8L V2 14-Pole, Kv 630, 8T, 14pole, D42 L52

DrMotor is offline  
Old 03-02-2013, 03:15 PM
  #9  
rosnik
Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: 1000MIGLIA CITY, ITALY
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?

Thank you DrMptor!
Nice woul be get one Exel file about you motors data.
rosnik is offline  
Old 03-03-2013, 06:57 AM
  #10  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?


ORIGINAL: rosnik
Thank you DrMotor! Nice woul be get one Exel file about you motors data.
Hello Rosnik, thanks for comment.
I do not have the data in a spreadsheet -however I could send a text file or a Word file with these data, if that might be any use.
If you PM mewith your email address, I will send
DrMotor is offline  
Old 03-03-2013, 07:19 AM
  #11  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?

For the avoidance of doubt, what I am suggesting very strongly in the lists above, is that the "=" sign means that the motors linked in this way are actually identical.
Theyhave the same internal parts, the same magnets and number of magnets,the same stator and windings. Themotors will of course have the same performance. Of course, all the motors in this list are manufactured side-by-side in the same factory.
This will hold, even if the motorshave a slightly differentexternal appearance, in terms of the style of the front and backend-housings, or the colour of the can and end housings. The external appearance of the motor is just cosmetic, and has no effect on its performance.
In some cases, the various brand name retailersselling the motor, might quoteslightly different Kv's for the motor, even if it is exactly the same motor. Possibly,measurements made by abrand name vendor may be slightly incorrect, or in some casesa vendormightchange the quoted Kv deliberately by 10 or 30 or 60 rpm,to makeit look like a different motor from the one being sold under a different brand name. However, if a motor made in the same factory with the same internal parts has, for instance,a 1709 stator with 9 wire turns, and has 12 magnet poles, and has the same weight and same external dimensions, it will be the same motor whether it has a quoted Kv of 1700 or 1580 ...

Just to take some examples:
Hacker A10-9L, Kv 1700, 9T is the same motor as the generic SunRay 1709-1580Kv 9T
This is also exactly the same motor as:
LiPolice1709/9T-1580KV
OKHobby Infinite A1709-1500, 9T
HYPERION Z1709-09T 1500 KV
Foxy C1709/09 1580 Kv
APACHE APM10-9T, Kv1700
Gens ACE Mars BL2122-1580KV, 9T
FURY SA-10-9L-1700 Kv, 9T


Hacker A20-30 M EVO, Kv 980, 30T is the same motor as the genericSunRay 2209-980Kv 30T
It is also the same motor as:
Torque 30T/980
Turnigy SK3 2826-980kv, 30T
LiPoliceLP-2209/30T-980KV
OK Hobby Infinite A2209-950, 30T
Foxy C2209/30 980 Kv
APACHE APM20-30T, 980 Kv
Gens ACE Mars BL2722-980KV, 30T
DrMotor is offline  
Old 03-03-2013, 07:26 AM
  #12  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



MOTORS OFTEN RECOMMENDED FOR A 30-SIZE PLANE: (e.g. Sebart, 3D Hobby Shop 30-size planes)

Hacker A30-14-L-V2, Kv 800, 14T is the same motor as Turnigy SK3 3542-800Kv 14T
It is also samemotor as:
Torque 2814T/820, Kv 820
APACHE APL30-14T 815 Kv
Nova Line DT3019/14-800
Gens ACE Mars BL3744-800KV, 14T



Hacker A30-12-L-V2, Kv 1000, 12T, is the same motor as generic SunRay 3020-970Kv 12T
It is also same motor as:
Turnigy SK3 3542-1000kv, 12T
LiPoliceLP-3020/12T-970KV
OKHobbyInfinite A3020-970, 12T
HYPERION Z3019-12T 900 KV
Foxy C3020/12 970Kv
Nova Line DT3019/12 970 Kv
Lipotech GTA 20-12 900 Kv


Hacker A30-10-L-V2, Kv 1185, 10T is the same motor asthe generic SunRay 3020-1135 10T
It is also the same motor as:
Turnigy SK33542-1185kv, 10T
LiPoliceLP-3020/10T-1135KV
OKHobbyInfinite A3020-1135, 10T
HYPERION Z3019-10T 1070 KV
Foxy C3020/10 1135 Kv
Lipotech GTA 20-10 1080 Kv
Pilotage Nova Line DT3019/10 Kv 1125
and may be the same motor as:
OS OMA-3820 Kv 1200

DrMotor is offline  
Old 03-03-2013, 07:36 AM
  #13  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



MOTORS OFTEN RECOMMENDED FOR A 50-SIZE PLANE (e.g. Sebart, 3D Hobby Shop 50-size planes)

Hacker A50-16-S-V2, Kv 378, 16T is same motor as genericSunRay 4025-385Kv 16T
This is also the same motor as:
LiPolice LP-4025 /16T-385KV
OKHobbyInfinite A4025-370, 16T
HYPERION Z4025 16 TURN 368 KV
Foxy C4025/16 385 Kv
Pilotage Nova Line DT4123/16 Kv378
APACHE APL41-16T 320 Kv
LipoTech GTA4520 -16 370 Kv
and may be the same motor as:
OS OMA-5025 Kv 375 (-also has 4025 stator)


Hacker A50-14-S-V2, Kv 424, 14T is same motor as APACHE APL41-14T 380 Kv and Pilotage Nova Line DT4123/14 Kv425


Hacker A50-12-S-V2, Kv 492, 12T is same motor as generic SunRay 4025-510Kv 12T
It is also same motor as:
LiPoliceLP-4025 /12T-510KV
OKHobbyInfinite A4025-505, 12T
HYPERION Z4025 12T 486 KV
APACHE APL41-12T 420 Kv
Nova Line DT4123/12 -473

DrMotor is offline  
Old 03-03-2013, 07:38 AM
  #14  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



MOTORS OFTEN RECOMMENDED FOR A 110-SIZE PLANE (e.g. Sebart, 3D Hobby Shop 110-size planes)

HackerA50-16-L-V2, Kv 272, 16T, is same motor asApache APM 5035-16T 270 Kv

HackerA50-14-L-V2, Kv 300, 14T is same motor asgeneric SunRay 4035-310Kv 14T
It is also same motor as:
LiPoliceLP-4035 /14T-310KV
OK HobbyInfinite A4035-300, 14T
HYPERION Z4035 14T 299 KV
Foxy C4035/14 310 Kv
Apache APM 5035-14T Kv 320
Nova Line DT4133/14-354
Lipotech GTA4530 -14 300 Kv


Hacker A50-12-L-V2, Kv 345, 12T is same motor asgenericSunRay 4035-375Kv 12T
It is also the same motor as:
LiPoliceLP-4035 /12T-375KV
OKHobby Infinite A4035-360, 12T
HYPERION Z4035 12T 343 KV
Foxy C4035/12 375 Kv

DrMotor is offline  
Old 03-03-2013, 09:42 AM
  #15  
rosnik
Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: 1000MIGLIA CITY, ITALY
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?

DrMotor,
Great and useful write up!

TNX!
rosnik is offline  
Old 03-03-2013, 01:04 PM
  #16  
carlnoki
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Woodbridge, VA
Posts: 70
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?

DrMotor

any idea who makes these motors?

thanks

http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/s...li_880kv_.html

carlnoki is offline  
Old 03-04-2013, 02:08 AM
  #17  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



ORIGINAL: carlnoki
any idea who makes these motors? -Turnigy T600 Brushless Outrunner for 600 Heli
We do know which factory manufactures these excellent heli motors.
Jason5001 -who works for HobbyKing -actually stated in one of the Turnigy T600 product discussions:
" ... FYI, TURNIGY outsorced the design and manufacture of this motor to the same factory that makes HACKER motors ..." - http://www.hobbyking.com/unitedhobbi...dproduct=11102
( -for some reason,Jason's comment has since been removed from this thread ...!)
http://forums.offshoreelectrics.com/...816#post180816

It is very clear, therefore, that this T600 motor is manufactured by the SunRay Technology factory -which also manufactures the HACKER motors.

If you look at thephotos of the LiPolice LPH-4025/6T-1300KV heli motor
http://www.der-schweighofer.at/artik...mit_6_mm_welle
-you will see that this motor has anidentical external appearance to theTurnigy T600 motor. All LiPolice motors are made in the SunRay Technology factory, confirming that theTurnigy T600 motor is certain to be made in the same factory.

Also see:http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showp...&postcount=210
and: http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1637085 -Looking for Turnigy T600 outrunner manufacturer/supplier

The Turnigy T600 Heli motors are labelled as "4030" -showing they have a 4030 stator, They are availableeither with 880, 1100 or 1400Kv.
They have 8 magnet poles, and 12 stator arms -according to comments made by users.

DrMotor is offline  
Old 03-04-2013, 06:46 PM
  #18  
carlnoki
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Woodbridge, VA
Posts: 70
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?

would be great if we could get a place here in the US that handles the T-600 motors.
carlnoki is offline  
Old 03-05-2013, 01:15 AM
  #19  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



I thought HobbyKing had a "warehouse" in USA -isthe T600motor not available directly from there ...?

There are some other choices:
1. Thereare some new OS heli motors coming out:
O.S. OMH-4535-560KV Brushless Outrunner 600-650 Heli -looks like will be ~$130
https://rcjapan.net/o-s-engine-o-s-e...khlv3rta7afeg0
http://www3.towerhobbies.com/cgi-bin...?&I=LXDDGR&P=7



2. E-flite 600 Heli Brushless Outrunner Motor (1130kV) $119
http://www.amainhobbies.com/product_...r-Motor-1130kV



3. Scorpion HKIII-4025 series $219 -for 600 Heli
http://www.scorpionsystem.com/catalo...40/hkiii-4025/

There seems to be no Turnigy SK3 motor for a 600 heli - http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/s...tors-Heli.html

That is just from a very quick look; No doubt there are many more ...

DrMotor is offline  
Old 03-05-2013, 05:01 AM
  #20  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



COMPARISON OF SOME MOTOR PRICES:
The motors in each list are all identical, have matching specs, and are all made in the SunRay Technology factory

Prices in order of ascending $



PARK FLYER -SIZE MOTORS, 55g
Turnigy SK3 2830-1020kv, 20T $17.85
Infinite A2213-1070, 20T $19.71
Gens ACE Mars BL2726, 20T $24.35 (18.64 euros)
LP-2213/20T-1080KV $33.72 (25.90 euros)
APACHE APL20-20T 1020 Kv $38.35 (36.10 CHF)
FURY SA-20-20L/1022Kv $40.00
Foxy C2213/20 1080 Kv $42.21 (£27.95)
Pilotage Nova Line DT2213/20-1022 $53.50 (435 UAH -Ukraine)
Hacker A20-20-L-EVO, Kv 1022, $54.88 in USA, $75.70 in UK
Torque 20T/1030 $59.99
HYPERION Z2213-20T 1025 KV $73.30, $39.96 from AircraftWorld

DrMotor is offline  
Old 03-05-2013, 05:44 AM
  #21  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?

1. Results are quite surprising; There is a huge range of price, for motors that are essentially identical, have identical specs, are made in the same factory, appear to use the same internal parts, have the same build quality, and will havethe sameperformance and lifespan.
The price of these Park Flyer motors varies all the way from $17 up to $75.70 (in UK) -and for identical motors made in the same factory.
That is a 4.3-fold difference in price ... -for what appear to be identical motors, made side-by-side in the same factory ...

2. Hacker motors cost 40% more in UK than in USA -so Hacker motors appear much more expensive in UK.

3. Hyperion Z motors purchased from Airstrike often cost more than the matching same-size identical Hacker motor; BUT if purchased from AircraftWorld, they are almost half the pricecompared toAirstrike.

4. Turnigy SK motors are generally about 30% of the price of the matching and equivalent same-size Hacker USA motor price.

5. Torque motors are about same price as Hacker USA,occasionally slightly more.

OK Hobby Infinitemotorsare ~35% to 40% of Hacker USA price
Gens Ace motors are~40% to 50% of Hacker USA price
LiPolice motorsare ~50 to 60% of Hacker USA price
Pelikan Foxy motors are ~75% of Hacker USA price
Pilotage Nova-Line motors are ~same price as Hacker USA.


-And all for the identical motor, made with same internal parts, side-by-side in the same factory.
DrMotor is offline  
Old 03-05-2013, 06:28 AM
  #22  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



FOR MOTOR PRICES:
Source of these data:
HACKER IN USA https://www.aero-model.com/8_69/Moto...50-Series.html
HACKER IN UK http://www.westlondonmodels.com/brands/Hacker/
TORQUE http://www.extremeflightrc.com/store...5d9c72c6981a27
TURNIGY SK3 http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/s...SortOrder=desc
LIPOLICE http://www.der-schweighofer.at/it/ca...ushless_motori
OK HOBBY http://www.okhobby.com/category.php?id_category=161&p=2
HYPERION http://www.airstrike.com.au/Hyperion%20Motors.htm and http://www.aircraft-world.com/shopdi...que+outrunners
PELIKAN FOXY http://www.puffinmodels.com/category.php?dept=281
NOVA LINE PILOTAGE http://www.pilotage-rc.com.ua/catalogue/85_/85_20/
SHULMAN FURY http://shulmanaviation.com/index.php...aec8973b92be66
GENS ACE http://www.gensace.com/epages/genspo...tegories/Motor
APACHE http://www.slowflyer.ch/elektro-antr...ache/index.php
O.S. http://www3.towerhobbies.com/cgi-bin...AdvancedSearch



DrMotor is offline  
Old 03-05-2013, 10:49 AM
  #23  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?

The motors in each list are all identical, have matching specs, and are all made in the SunRay Technology factory
Prices in order of ascending $

30-SIZE MOTORS, 143g
Turnigy SK3 3542-800Kv 14T $35.81
Gens ACE Mars BL3744-800KV, 14T $42.07 (32.32 euros)
APACHE APL30-14T 815 Kv $66.51 (62.60 CHF)
Pilotage Nova Line DT3019/14-800 $78.72 (640 UAH)
Hacker A30-14-L-V2, Kv 800 $79.99 in USA, $100.24 in UK ($118 from Conrad UK ...!)
Torque 2814T/820 143g; Kv 820 $79.99

30-SIZE MOTORS, 177g
Infinite A3025-770, 12T $35.29
Turnigy SK3 3548-700kv, 12T $36.32
Gens ACE Mars BL3749-770KV, 12T$44.73 (34.35 euros)
LP-3025/12T-770KV $51.96 (39.90 euros)
APACHE APXL30-12T 750 Kv $71.63 (67.40 CHF)
Foxy C3025/12 770 Kv $75.49 (£49.95)
OS OMA-3825 Kv 750 $79.98
Torque 2812T/720, Kv 720 $84.95
Pilotage Nova Line DT3025/12-750 $87.94 (715 UAH)
Hacker A30-12 XL V3, Kv 700$89.99 in USA, $111.89 in UK ($132 from Conrad UK ...!)
HYPERION Z3025-12T 685 KV $121.70,$66.36 from AircraftWorld
DrMotor is offline  
Old 03-05-2013, 10:56 AM
  #24  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



The motors in each list are all identical, have matching specs, and are all made in the SunRay Technology factory
Prices in order of ascending $

50-SIZE MOTORS, 345g
Infinite A4025-370, 16T $50.88
LP-4025 /16T-385KV $68.86 (52.90 euros)
Foxy C4025/16 385 Kv $107.16 (£70.95)
OS OMA-5025 Kv 375 $119.98
Pilotage Nova Line DT4123/16 Kv378 $120.29 (978 UAH)
APACHE APL41-16T 320 Kv $121.97 (114.70 CHF)
Hacker A50-16-S-V2, Kv 378 $129.99 in USA, $173.64 in UK ($209 from Conrad UK)
HYPERION Z4025 16T 368 KV $164.90, $65.89 from AircraftWorld




50-SIZE MOTORS, 430g
Infinite A4035-300, 14T $55.88
LP-4035 /14T-310KV $81.92 (62.90 euros)
Foxy C4035/14 310 Kv $123.86 (£81.95)
Pilotage Nova Line DT4133/14-354 $134.56 (1094 UAH)
HYPERION Z4035 14T 299 KV $165.80, $75.80 from AircraftWorld
Hacker A50-14-L-V2, Kv 300 $169.99 in USA,$214.55 in UK ($254 from Conrad UK ..!)



DrMotor is offline  
Old 03-06-2013, 03:54 AM
  #25  
DrMotor
Senior Member
Thread Starter
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: M, S, NEW ZEALAND
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default RE: Which chinese factories make various brushless motor brands?



The motors in each list are all identical, have matching specs, and are all made in the SunRay Technology factory
Prices in order of ascending $

60 SIZE MOTORS, 590g
Infinite A5030-235, 20T $99.41
LP-5030 /20T-235KV $149.65 (114.90 euros)
Hacker A60-20S V2 28pole, Kv 245 $214.99 in USA, $297.53 in UK
HYPERION Z5025 20T 235 KV $274.90, $95.90 from AircraftWorld


60 SIZE MOTORS, 760g
Turnigy SK3 6364-190kv, 18T$70.47
Hacker A60-18 M, Kv 190 $239.99 in USA, $325.51 in UK
Hyperion Z5035-18, 18T, 190Kv $295.60, $103.10 from AircraftWorld

DrMotor is offline  

Thread Tools
Search this Thread

Contact Us - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service - Do Not Sell My Personal Information

Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.