While AMA talks, FAA acts...
#226

My Feedback: (29)
i do not believe i ever said it was a title, just a job description of sorts..
now for the record, he was a district contest coordinator at the time and used his inside with the AMA to find and release on open forum some of my personal details.
and i was not the only one he treated in such a manor.
they can speak up is they wish to, not my place to name them.
now for the record, he was a district contest coordinator at the time and used his inside with the AMA to find and release on open forum some of my personal details.
and i was not the only one he treated in such a manor.
they can speak up is they wish to, not my place to name them.
There still is no such thing as a district contest coordinator. Each club has their appointed contest director that approves along with the club board competitive events for the year. He works with special interest groups such as IMAC, NSRCA, NMPRA, LSF, AILS League etc. to put together a schedule. The ONLY thing with a District title is the AVP. The only thing he has to do with contests is make sure they are operated in a safe manner. I have seen an AVP take action twice in my 40 years As an AMA member.
Could you have had an issue with someone within the AMA. Certainly, we are all human after all. However it always takes two to tangle. There is more to the story I am sure.
Last edited by speedracerntrixie; 01-13-2019 at 07:38 AM.
#227

My Feedback: (29)
Hydro and Appowner. First off thank you. Those last two posts seemed to have the attitude dialed down and I wanted to let you know I appreciate it. In regards to the cost of items on base, perhaps the Air Force is different. Prior to my father retiring we lived on base at Travis. I remember many trips to the commissary with my mother. When my parents split I went with my father and we lived in Fairfield. My dad still drove onto base ( 12 miles ) to buy groceries and gas.
Appowner, regardless of whether you want it or not any and all servicemen have my appreciation. That is the attitude I must carry with me everyday into work. I'm certain that you recall me saying that my career for the past 20 years has been working for defense contractors such as Lockheed Martin, L3 and Aerojet Rocketdyne. Truth is that I have most likely had my hands on just as many programs as guys in the military. That is what I presently do for my country. I will also early next month be putting my youngest son on a bus to Camp Pendleton. I am very proud of him but as you can imagine there are mixed emotions.
Now back to thread topic. We should be able to share our points of Veiw without it getting nasty. We all,are adults right. I get it that some of you have had bad experiences with either the AMA or clubs. We all have the right to enjoy our hobby the way we want as long as it is done legally and safely. As long as those two items are met neither side of this devide is not doing any harm to the other. Yes the financials of the AMA look bad right now. All organizations go through such challenges. Look at Sears right now. The AMA has survived multiple wars and conflicts and several recessions. I am confident they will survive this as well. If not I see the seperate special interest groups stepping into the CBO role. The dues collecting club environment is never going to go away. As far as guys within the AMA not voting, IMO that means that those guys are happy with the way things are being run. Just like here on RCU. We have hundreds of AMA members that are also regular contributors here on RCG. How many of them come into the AMA forum and post? I see only a handful. People generally only voice their opinions when there is something to complain about otherwise they rather remain quiet. How many times have we all complained about a server at a restaurant? How many have taken the time to ask for a manager and wait around to tell them you received great service? Nobody here is going to end up being The savior of the hobby.
Appowner, regardless of whether you want it or not any and all servicemen have my appreciation. That is the attitude I must carry with me everyday into work. I'm certain that you recall me saying that my career for the past 20 years has been working for defense contractors such as Lockheed Martin, L3 and Aerojet Rocketdyne. Truth is that I have most likely had my hands on just as many programs as guys in the military. That is what I presently do for my country. I will also early next month be putting my youngest son on a bus to Camp Pendleton. I am very proud of him but as you can imagine there are mixed emotions.
Now back to thread topic. We should be able to share our points of Veiw without it getting nasty. We all,are adults right. I get it that some of you have had bad experiences with either the AMA or clubs. We all have the right to enjoy our hobby the way we want as long as it is done legally and safely. As long as those two items are met neither side of this devide is not doing any harm to the other. Yes the financials of the AMA look bad right now. All organizations go through such challenges. Look at Sears right now. The AMA has survived multiple wars and conflicts and several recessions. I am confident they will survive this as well. If not I see the seperate special interest groups stepping into the CBO role. The dues collecting club environment is never going to go away. As far as guys within the AMA not voting, IMO that means that those guys are happy with the way things are being run. Just like here on RCU. We have hundreds of AMA members that are also regular contributors here on RCG. How many of them come into the AMA forum and post? I see only a handful. People generally only voice their opinions when there is something to complain about otherwise they rather remain quiet. How many times have we all complained about a server at a restaurant? How many have taken the time to ask for a manager and wait around to tell them you received great service? Nobody here is going to end up being The savior of the hobby.
Last edited by speedracerntrixie; 01-13-2019 at 07:41 AM.
#228
Fliers, thanks for the post. That brought back some fond, and not so fond memories. I looked it up a long time ago but thought I`d try it again: Typed in "Big Bambu" on ebay and there they were, still available, the LP with the giant paper inside. What a hoot!
You Navy guys remember the slogan "Not In My Navy"? Right before that they were playing the movie "Up In Smoke" at the base theater where I was stationed at NAS Kingsville,TX just before the excrement really hit the fan.
You Navy guys remember the slogan "Not In My Navy"? Right before that they were playing the movie "Up In Smoke" at the base theater where I was stationed at NAS Kingsville,TX just before the excrement really hit the fan.
#229
Banned
BTW, last I knew (18 mo ago) the Commissary saved you about 6%. But most of the savings were in the odd or unusual products. Doing comparative shopping with the economy would save even more. Depended too on what state you were in. Gas would run anywhere from a couple of cents per gal more to 10 cents less. Just depends on when you hit the pumps. I was 5 miles from the Fort Gas Station and rarely used it.
Lots of services on bases today are being sub contracted to major corporations. To include housing. Base housing you now pay rent. It equals your allowance but now utilities have been added to the tab as well. I don't know if it's everywhere yet as it's a fairly new program. But it's all over the DC area.
Last edited by Appowner; 01-13-2019 at 07:48 AM.
#231
All of the threads in the AMA forum could be very useful if they didn't get so "adversarial". What should be happening is we should be looking at ways to fix the issues rather than arguing over whether the issue is actually an issue or a fabrication.
We all know the FAA has posted on their website that the 400 foot limit is now going to be enforced.
We all know the AMA has put out that the FAA isn't enforcing the 400 foot limit and it's an "advisory"
We now need to figure out how to reconcile the two stories. The big questions now are:
1) What is truth and what isn't?
2) How do we determine what is the truth and what isn't?
So any thoughts on all of this?
#233

My Feedback: (29)
I am all for keeping an open mind. Yes the FAA has on that particular page that we are to fly at 400' or less. It also on the same page references section 336. From what I am reading is that the new laws requiring 400' are not in place as of yet.
The resolve to that would be a simple one. The FAA has the email addresses of everyone who registered, they have the ability to keep us updated. Has anyone who is currently registered gotten a confirmation email from the FAA? I haven't.
The current goverment shutdown is going to slow things down a bit however what I see happening is that the FAA will be putting together an exemption for CBO sites the same as they have in Canada. I honestly feel that would be the best solution for the majority.
Right now we are at a "wait and see" point. The reality is that there is not an enforcement tool in place. At least in my area the police are not concerned with guys flying models at club fields. The only time any police officer will act on somebody flying a model is if there has been a complaint. That opinion comes from a few family members that are law enforcement.
Until I hear any differently I will continue to fly as I always have.
The resolve to that would be a simple one. The FAA has the email addresses of everyone who registered, they have the ability to keep us updated. Has anyone who is currently registered gotten a confirmation email from the FAA? I haven't.
The current goverment shutdown is going to slow things down a bit however what I see happening is that the FAA will be putting together an exemption for CBO sites the same as they have in Canada. I honestly feel that would be the best solution for the majority.
Right now we are at a "wait and see" point. The reality is that there is not an enforcement tool in place. At least in my area the police are not concerned with guys flying models at club fields. The only time any police officer will act on somebody flying a model is if there has been a complaint. That opinion comes from a few family members that are law enforcement.
Until I hear any differently I will continue to fly as I always have.
#234
Now back to thread topic. We should be able to share our points of Veiw without it getting nasty. We all,are adults right. I get it that some of you have had bad experiences with either the AMA or clubs. We all have the right to enjoy our hobby the way we want as long as it is done legally and safely. As long as those two items are met neither side of this devide is not doing any harm to the other. Yes the financials of the AMA look bad right now. All organizations go through such challenges. Look at Sears right now. The AMA has survived multiple wars and conflicts and several recessions. I am confident they will survive this as well. If not I see the seperate special interest groups stepping into the CBO role. The dues collecting club environment is never going to go away. As far as guys within the AMA not voting, IMO that means that those guys are happy with the way things are being run. Just like here on RCU. We have hundreds of AMA members that are also regular contributors here on RCG. How many of them come into the AMA forum and post? I see only a handful. People generally only voice their opinions when there is something to complain about otherwise they rather remain quiet. How many times have we all complained about a server at a restaurant? How many have taken the time to ask for a manager and wait around to tell them you received great service? Nobody here is going to end up being The savior of the hobby.
1) K Mart went into bankruptcy protection due to mismanagement and overexpansion
2) K Mart was able to somehow aquire Sears as it came out of it's bankruptcy
3) Somehow, the K Mart CEO was able to keep his position in the merged corporation
4) Somehow, the K Mart CEO was able to keep his job, even though he oversaw the company again start to fail
5) Somehow, the K Mart CEO was able to keep his job while shutting down stores under both brand names while not keeping product on the store shelves or do any maintenance on the stores. Many of the stores are literally falling apart
6) When the two chains merged in 2005, the total chain was 3500 stores
7) Somehow the K Mart CEO was able to keep his job, even though he's put the corporation back under bankruptcy protection
8) Despite its struggles, Sears CEO gets raise. Sears CEO Eddie Lampert only gets a salary of $1 a year to run the troubled retailer. But he does get a stock bonus, and for 2017 that bonus increased by $850,000, giving him a 24% raise
9) Since 2005, the chain has gone from 3500 stores to 2000 in 2013 to 866 as of September 13, 2018
10) On October 15, 2018, Lampert stepped down as CEO of Sears Holdings, while remaining Chairman of the Board, as part of Sears Holdings bankruptcy actions. On December 6, 2018 Lampert, through his company ESL Investments, offered to buy all of Sears for $4.6 billion dollars in cash and stock.[18] The offer would be financed by $950 million in added debt,[18] but no additional cash.[19] Five hundred stores remain in operation; the remainder are in liquidation
Does this sound familiar at all?
#235

My Feedback: (1)
This is the exact same mentality that is so wrong with the AMA right now. In my opinion, the "good ole boy" network is, and has been, the biggest problem at Muncie and within many of our clubs.
Anyone is free to express their opinions here, if you can't handle others' opinions, you should re-evaluate your participation here, not shut everyone else out.
Astro
#236

My Feedback: (29)
Why? Freedom of speech and individual opinions is one of the most sacred of rights that we enjoy in this country.
This is the exact same mentality that is so wrong with the AMA right now. In my opinion, the "good ole boy" network is, and has been, the biggest problem at Muncie and within many of our clubs.
Anyone is free to express their opinions here, if you can't handle others' opinions, you should re-evaluate your participation here, not shut everyone else out.
Astro
This is the exact same mentality that is so wrong with the AMA right now. In my opinion, the "good ole boy" network is, and has been, the biggest problem at Muncie and within many of our clubs.
Anyone is free to express their opinions here, if you can't handle others' opinions, you should re-evaluate your participation here, not shut everyone else out.
Astro
While you are correct that shutting it down is an oppression to freedom of speech, it is also IMO is damaging to the hobby as a whole. Complaining online about any organization is simply a waste of time. If you really want changes they have to happen from within. The resolve is join and run for office if it really is this important to you.
As far as " the good 'ole boys" are concerned. Would that title not apply to you, Hydro, Appowner and Franklin as well within this forum?
#237
When the wife and I were on a cruise last October, we asked to speak to some of the galley staff to personally thank them for what we were eating. We also talked to the hotel manager and told him how great our cabin steward was in taking care of our cabin and handling any requests we had. When we returned home, we received a survey from the cruise line, in this case Royal Caribbean. We praised our cabin steward again as well as our wait staff in the main dining room, each one by name.
#238

My Feedback: (1)
My experience has shown that low voter turnout has more to do with ignorance and lack of engagement at any other level than wanting to fly, NOT because they believe everything is hunky-dory. Moreover, these AMA members (and I would venture it is the vast majority, based on my experience) rely on the "good ole boy" information network to keep them up-to-date regarding AMA issues. Ever hear the saying, "Don't mind the man behind the curtain.."
It is for this very reason that these forums are important. I have witnessed new club members that were very intimidated to speak up at club meetings due to the "good ole boys", where they are more likely to jump in here and share their experience and opinions.
Regards,
Astro
#241
While you are correct that shutting it down is an oppression to freedom of speech, it is also IMO is damaging to the hobby as a whole. Complaining online about any organization is simply a waste of time. If you really want changes they have to happen from within. The resolve is join and run for office if it really is this important to you.
As far as " the good 'ole boys" are concerned. Would that title not apply to you, Hydro, Appowner and Franklin as well within this forum?
As far as " the good 'ole boys" are concerned. Would that title not apply to you, Hydro, Appowner and Franklin as well within this forum?
Actually, calling us "the good 'ole boys" does not apply. WE are not trying to run or control anything, which is usually the case with that name. We are calling out those that are doing what I said above.
#243

My Feedback: (29)
When you throw Sears into the conversation, you have to look at what led Sears to the situation it's in now. Let me fill in the blanks:
1) K Mart went into bankruptcy protection due to mismanagement and overexpansion
2) K Mart was able to somehow aquire Sears as it came out of it's bankruptcy
3) Somehow, the K Mart CEO was able to keep his position in the merged corporation
4) Somehow, the K Mart CEO was able to keep his job, even though he oversaw the company again start to fail
5) Somehow, the K Mart CEO was able to keep his job while shutting down stores under both brand names while not keeping product on the store shelves or do any maintenance on the stores. Many of the stores are literally falling apart
6) When the two chains merged in 2005, the total chain was 3500 stores
7) Somehow the K Mart CEO was able to keep his job, even though he's put the corporation back under bankruptcy protection
8) Despite its struggles, Sears CEO gets raise. Sears CEO Eddie Lampert only gets a salary of $1 a year to run the troubled retailer. But he does get a stock bonus, and for 2017 that bonus increased by $850,000, giving him a 24% raise
9) Since 2005, the chain has gone from 3500 stores to 2000 in 2013 to 866 as of September 13, 2018
10) On October 15, 2018, Lampert stepped down as CEO of Sears Holdings, while remaining Chairman of the Board, as part of Sears Holdings bankruptcy actions. On December 6, 2018 Lampert, through his company ESL Investments, offered to buy all of Sears for $4.6 billion dollars in cash and stock.[18] The offer would be financed by $950 million in added debt,[18] but no additional cash.[19] Five hundred stores remain in operation; the remainder are in liquidation
Does this sound familiar at all?
1) K Mart went into bankruptcy protection due to mismanagement and overexpansion
2) K Mart was able to somehow aquire Sears as it came out of it's bankruptcy
3) Somehow, the K Mart CEO was able to keep his position in the merged corporation
4) Somehow, the K Mart CEO was able to keep his job, even though he oversaw the company again start to fail
5) Somehow, the K Mart CEO was able to keep his job while shutting down stores under both brand names while not keeping product on the store shelves or do any maintenance on the stores. Many of the stores are literally falling apart
6) When the two chains merged in 2005, the total chain was 3500 stores
7) Somehow the K Mart CEO was able to keep his job, even though he's put the corporation back under bankruptcy protection
8) Despite its struggles, Sears CEO gets raise. Sears CEO Eddie Lampert only gets a salary of $1 a year to run the troubled retailer. But he does get a stock bonus, and for 2017 that bonus increased by $850,000, giving him a 24% raise
9) Since 2005, the chain has gone from 3500 stores to 2000 in 2013 to 866 as of September 13, 2018
10) On October 15, 2018, Lampert stepped down as CEO of Sears Holdings, while remaining Chairman of the Board, as part of Sears Holdings bankruptcy actions. On December 6, 2018 Lampert, through his company ESL Investments, offered to buy all of Sears for $4.6 billion dollars in cash and stock.[18] The offer would be financed by $950 million in added debt,[18] but no additional cash.[19] Five hundred stores remain in operation; the remainder are in liquidation
Does this sound familiar at all?
I do agree that AMA needs to be run better. Do cuts need to be made? Yes. More importantly we ALL need to work on making this a popular hobby again. We need more members so we have a bigger voice with lawmakers.
I also know that when staffing you need to look at what the median pay median pay is for that particular position in that particular region and pay competitively regardless of the health of the organization. Would you accept a position that payed less then the median because the organization was struggling?
I have payed my dues being in the hobby industry. I have seen many businesses and shops fail. Most of these were being operated like a large cooperation. The standard business model just does not work well in the hobby industry. Use Tower Hobbies as an example. Fact is most successful hobby shops have been operated by guys with little to no business education. Examples: San Antonio Hobbies ( shop that I managed the R/C department ) Sheldon's Hobbies, Dons hobby shop, Tammies Hobbies, D&J Hobbies. Granted, most of these stores are now gone however at the height of the hobbys popularity were very profitable. When I worked at San Antonio during December the cash registers had to be emptied twice a day because the 20, 50, 100 dollar bills and charge slips under the cash trays would stack up to the point we couldn't close the registers. Two things have changed since then, mail order and the popularity.
#245
You may be right, but I doubt it. The AMA is a perceived joke when you look at what's happening on Capitol Hill. I also don't see how the FAA can give an exemption to anyone that is more than a special event exemption. When I go to a boat race, the club I belong to has to have a permit to shut down the water. Never have we obtained a long term permit, just 24 to 48 hours at most. I suspect the FAA would do the same thing
#246
What would worry me isn't what we're saying as much as the information Franklin has obtained and posted. That should worry the AMA to no end as it would prevent me from ever applying for membership due to how wasteful the AMA is shown to be. Since Franklin is posting information that the AMA had itself put out, they also don't have any way to discredit him for doing so
#247
Banned
I'm just wondering if you guys actually read and understand what the FAA has said?
"Fly at or below 400 feet when in uncontrolled airspace (Class G)"
Class 'G' airspace is UN-CONTROLLED. Everything else IS controlled as in falls under direct ATC in some way. In class G full size are expected to stay at least 500 feet up (except when taking off, landing, crop dusting, etc.)
IF AMA gets waivers, I seriously doubt they will be for Class G airspace. And either way, I fully expect such waivers to be challenged in court as unconstitutional.
And near as I can tell, Speedy's club site is in Class 'C' (controlled) airspace. So I suspect the local ATC is well aware of their activities and has given them a pass to a specific altitude. Perhaps a permanent NOTAM for the full size guys. If true (the pass) and Speedy withheld the info intentionally, it again goes to show his real intentions and character.
"Fly at or below 400 feet when in uncontrolled airspace (Class G)"
Class 'G' airspace is UN-CONTROLLED. Everything else IS controlled as in falls under direct ATC in some way. In class G full size are expected to stay at least 500 feet up (except when taking off, landing, crop dusting, etc.)
IF AMA gets waivers, I seriously doubt they will be for Class G airspace. And either way, I fully expect such waivers to be challenged in court as unconstitutional.
And near as I can tell, Speedy's club site is in Class 'C' (controlled) airspace. So I suspect the local ATC is well aware of their activities and has given them a pass to a specific altitude. Perhaps a permanent NOTAM for the full size guys. If true (the pass) and Speedy withheld the info intentionally, it again goes to show his real intentions and character.
#248
#249

My Feedback: (1)
Unfortunately, there is no way of knowing whether a newcomers' experience on these forums actually keep them from visiting a field. I HAVE however, witnessed many occasions where the GOB network at local clubs have intimidated a potential new member where they never came back.
Astro




There , fixed it for ya ...
Exactly .