Dual elevator servos?
#26
Thread Starter
Personally, I'm not a fan of touch screens. (And no, I don't own a smart phone...or any cell phone for that matter.) Up to now, the RDS8000 has been as "complicated" as any radio I had ever hoped to use. Which is to say I hoped never to have to use anything more complicated. But the prospect of flying bigger and more complex models (though I''ll never be flying anything other than WWI other than for practice) makes a few "fancier" features like throttle curves appealing.
#27
My Feedback: (19)
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Arlington TX
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Start by plugging one servo into channel 1 and the other channel 7.
turn on radio and hit end button several times to get home. Push left arrow once to highlight ETC menu at top right of screen.
Push the down button until the screen reads "BASIC". Does it show ON or OFF?
turn on radio and hit end button several times to get home. Push left arrow once to highlight ETC menu at top right of screen.
Push the down button until the screen reads "BASIC". Does it show ON or OFF?
Last edited by gravityking; 01-03-2015 at 06:58 PM.
#28
My Feedback: (44)
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Golden,
CO
Posts: 695
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There is a theory that 2 elevator servos gives you a slight safety benefit due to the redundancy. That if one elevator servo screws up, you have a chance of being able to save the airplane. Like if the ailerons go, you still have the rudder. I am NOT volunteering to test the theory.
I have had this happen on a Goldberg Ultimate 1.20 Bipe and a TF 1/7 scale Mustang. Saved both planes when otherwise they would have been lost. Do a YouTube search on dual elevator servos and the RSD 8000. You Tube and Google are your best friends many time when you don't know how to do something.
Maybe this will help.
http://rcheliguy.com/global/airtroni...ra%20Stick.pdf
#30
My Feedback: (29)
Agreed, my race airplanes are set up with dual elevator servos under the wing and independant pushrods. The secon race of this season I was clipped in the tail by another airplane. The impact jammed my right elevator about 1/4" in the up position. Being that the other elevator half was untouched I was able to land. Video is on YouTube, search " Was it a midair at the T-34 race "
#31
My Feedback: (1)
I've never had a model with a servo for each elevator half (in the tail). So how do I do the radio setup for this? In my hazy thinking I imagined I could just connect the two with a Y-harness and then a long lead to the Rx. But the Y-harness reverses one servo. Or is there some other type of Y-harness needed? Or is the additional elevator servo also connected to the Rx, and if so how?
I'm using an 8-ch Airtronics RDS8000.
I'm using an 8-ch Airtronics RDS8000.
#32
My Feedback: (211)
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Sun City,
AZ
Posts: 286
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Abu, a picture is worth a thousand words...have you looked at any the videos on the you tube site. I don't use Airtronics but surely you must have a couple of programmable mixes in there...where you can plug the right elevator into the elevator and the left elevator into aux 1 or 2 and then slave the aux channel to the master elevator. You do the ailerons in the same manner, except IF you have two aileron servos per wing then you are going to need either a matchbox and a Y harness or perhaps one of the buses from Smartfly or Powerbox to match then up. Ideally, you are not going to need a big adjustment if you can keep the geometry symmetrical on the linkages and mechanically adjust the errors out before you start in with the radio adjustments. When matching up the two elevator halves...use a rigid tube (CF works well) mounted to each elevator top snugly with painters tape and the ends extending out behind the rudder on the centerline. The tube ends should nearly touch each other...this will allow you to visually see and adjust the variation out of the entire travel and it should be fairly close if you start with just the sub and end points.
#33
My Feedback: (22)
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: palm harbor,
FL
Posts: 2,232
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I haven't used air tropics in years but the simplest way is Y harness with a servo reverser.or use a match box.a few bucks more but then how much have got invested in your prize bird.i always avoided twin elevators as it was truly a pain programing.to my suprise when I transitioned to a new futaba 8 radio I had to set up split elevators for my 30 cc edge and when I made a few simple connections and touched a couple button I was so amazed it just workeno zeroing out no mixing.what a great systemd
#34
My Feedback: (1)
The function in my radio is "Ailevator".
This is the same as the dual battery issue. You can make this as simple or complicated as you wish. If you maintain symmetrical geometry with your horns and linkages, and you have your horns on the right side of the servo, a Y harness will suffice.
Remember the days when we did not have servo reversing? It can be done without all of the xtra boxes and such.
This is the same as the dual battery issue. You can make this as simple or complicated as you wish. If you maintain symmetrical geometry with your horns and linkages, and you have your horns on the right side of the servo, a Y harness will suffice.
Remember the days when we did not have servo reversing? It can be done without all of the xtra boxes and such.
#35
My Feedback: (29)
The problem is not the linkage geometry. I have been doing servo matching either through the TX or matching devices in IMAC airplanes for over 13 years. The issue is that no two servos have exactly the same sweep. They really should but they don't. I'm very particular on setups and what makes my head explode may not be a big deal to others.
#36
My Feedback: (1)
The problem is not the linkage geometry. I have been doing servo matching either through the TX or matching devices in IMAC airplanes for over 13 years. The issue is that no two servos have exactly the same sweep. They really should but they don't. I'm very particular on setups and what makes my head explode may not be a big deal to others.
#37
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Moss Vale, NSW, AUSTRALIA
Posts: 181
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
SImple solution for me is to buy Digital servo's that can be programmed, then just reverse one servo via programming and it will run on a Y lead. Yes you can buy powerboxes, I own a couple, but I still reverse servos via programming if I need to and I can.
Last edited by mackeyjones; 01-03-2015 at 11:42 PM.
#38
Thread Starter
One problem arises, however. As was discussed in another thread, I was planning to use a simple dual battery/dual switch setup for power. Going the KISS route mean plugging the two power sources into two Rx slots. So with two slots for the elevator, two slots for the ailerons, there's just not enough slots on a 8ch Rx for everything. Something has to go.
#42
Thread Starter
I'm glad you guys are around to untangle my brain! Just for the symmetry of the thing, would there be anything wrong (or pointless) about running both batteries (and their switches) through a Y-harness into the usual one power slot?
It's turning my brain inside out to think of plugging an aileron into one side of a Y-harness and a battery into the other.
It's turning my brain inside out to think of plugging an aileron into one side of a Y-harness and a battery into the other.
Last edited by abufletcher; 01-04-2015 at 06:27 AM.
#44
My Feedback: (19)
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Arlington TX
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yes, Y the batteries, use 1 & 7 for your elevators. If you made your way into the deluxe menu then you have already turned off BASIC. Look for a "D-EL" mix. It will show "INH" by default so hit the "YES" button once to change it to "ACT". That's it!
if your lucky the elevators will work as needed. If they go opposite each other or backwards from the stick, go into servo reversing and change 1 or 7 or both.
if your lucky the elevators will work as needed. If they go opposite each other or backwards from the stick, go into servo reversing and change 1 or 7 or both.
#46
My Feedback: (1)
Don, now you are realizing the trouble you get into with so many servos, and trying to mix them all together. You run out of slots in your RX to receive all of these servos. This is one of the reasons why power expanders are used, as they facilitate more servos with more servo ports. As, again, with IMAC style aircraft, which seem to be the type of aircraft that have really driven these technologies.
I use Y harnesses on my batteries on most of my planes to free up these slots.
Just an FYI, I currently am flying a Great Planes 50cc sized Ultimate biplane. It has 4 aileron servos. All of them are on Y harnesses and it is working fine.
There are some little things you have to deal with when electronically mixing, that you are going to run into. Like getting the slaved servo to move with the trim switch. They have to be linked properly, or sometimes only the master will move with trim. All of this depends on your TX.
It is good to get experience with this stuff though, so play around with what set up works best for you. You can always go back and change it to a different configuration later if do not like it.
I use Y harnesses on my batteries on most of my planes to free up these slots.
Just an FYI, I currently am flying a Great Planes 50cc sized Ultimate biplane. It has 4 aileron servos. All of them are on Y harnesses and it is working fine.
There are some little things you have to deal with when electronically mixing, that you are going to run into. Like getting the slaved servo to move with the trim switch. They have to be linked properly, or sometimes only the master will move with trim. All of this depends on your TX.
It is good to get experience with this stuff though, so play around with what set up works best for you. You can always go back and change it to a different configuration later if do not like it.
#48
My Feedback: (19)
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Arlington TX
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
He's already read page 62 and correct me if I'm wrong but seems overwhelmed by the "stereo instruction" layout of the manual. Also if you use the D-EL mix there is no slaving or individual trimming or issues related to slaving the second elevator half. It's a " boxed" mix and requires nothing other than reversing one to match the other. It's just not as complicated as being made out. 3 steps, done, in the air.
Also the batteries can be double Y'd along with a servo so no receiver port needs to be used exclusively for the batteries.
Also the batteries can be double Y'd along with a servo so no receiver port needs to be used exclusively for the batteries.
Last edited by gravityking; 01-04-2015 at 10:35 AM.
#49
My Feedback: (35)
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Lynnfield,
MA
Posts: 195
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Here ya go....try this device from smart fly. Works great and better than a reversing Y cable.
http://smart-fly.com/index.php?route...&product_id=62
http://smart-fly.com/index.php?route...&product_id=62
I've never had a model with a servo for each elevator half (in the tail). So how do I do the radio setup for this? In my hazy thinking I imagined I could just connect the two with a Y-harness and then a long lead to the Rx. But the Y-harness reverses one servo. Or is there some other type of Y-harness needed? Or is the additional elevator servo also connected to the Rx, and if so how?
I'm using an 8-ch Airtronics RDS8000.
I'm using an 8-ch Airtronics RDS8000.